Sections
Long-Term Adverse Health Outcomes | Protective Factors | Postconcussion Symptoms Following Concussion/mTBI | Disability | Disorders of Consciousness | Mortality
Excerpt
Of particular concern after TBI are adverse outcomes that
affect health and the ability to function in society. The Institute of Medicine (2009) Committee on Gulf War and Health recently
conducted a large-scale and detailed systematic review of the literature
to answer the question, "What are the long-term outcomes
associated with sustaining TBI?" The committee reported
significant limitations in many of the existing studies, including
reliance on self-report, small sample sizes, lack of uniformity
in defining TBI severity, and inadequate comparison groups. However,
they also found evidence in the literature of a range of adverse
long-term health outcomes (lasting greater than 6 months)
associated with moderate and severe TBI and mild TBI with LOC. The
committee's main findings for the studies that could be
categorized by TBI severity are summarized in Table 1–5.
According to the committee, evidence of long-term adverse health
effects was strongest for moderate, severe, and penetrating TBI
and limited or inadequate for concussion/mTBI. The evidence
of an association between concussion/mTBI alone and long-term
neurocognitive deficits (defined as performance on tests of sensory
integrity, motor speed and coordination, attention, processing,
and executive functions) was found to be insufficient/inadequate
based on the published literature to date. The committee also found
insufficient/inadequate evidence for the association between
concussion/mTBI and long-term social and occupational dysfunction.
Although they concluded on the basis of combined results from studies
of a range of TBI severity that there is sufficient evidence of
an association between sustaining a TBI and development of postconcussive
symptoms (such as memory problems, dizziness, and irritability),
this finding is problematic. Specifically, there was no adequate
evaluation of the association of concussion/mTBI alone
with postconcussive symptoms because in some studies, data were
not analyzed separately for concussion/mTBI and moderate/severe
TBI, or postconcussion-symptom inventories were used to assess symptoms
in persons who had moderate to severe TBI. The failure to separate concussion/mTBI
from moderate/severe TBI in the evaluation of postconcussive
symptoms is a problem in some natural history studies of TBI.