Psychiatrist and Nonpsychiatrist Physician Network Breadth in Dual Eligible Special Needs Plans

Dual Eligible Special Needs Plans (D-SNPs) are a type of Medicare Advantage (MA) plan for individuals who have both Medicare and Medicaid coverage. The authors compared the breadths of psychiatrist and nonpsychiatrist provider networks in D-SNPs and other MA plans.

MA plan provider network data were merged with plan service areas and a nationwide provider database to form a data set with 843 observations on networks subclassified by state and network type (D-SNP or other MA) covering 42 U.S. states and Washington, D.C. Network breadth measured the in-network fraction of clinically active Medicare-accepting psychiatrists and other physician providers in the plans’ service areas in each state. Regression analyses were used to compare psychiatrist and nonpsychiatrist network breadth and psychiatrist-nonpsychiatrist breadth differences between D-SNPs and other MA plans, after adjustment for state-level differences.

Mean psychiatrist network breadth was 0.319 in D-SNPs and 0.299 in other MA plans, and nonpsychiatrist network breadth was 0.346 in D-SNPs and 0.358 in other MA plans. Psychiatrist networks were narrower than nonpsychiatrist networks (0.303 vs. 0.355, p<0.001), but mean psychiatrist network breadth did not differ between D-SNPs and other MA plans. In regression analyses, the psychiatrist-nonpsychiatrist breadth difference was smaller in D-SNPs (−0.031) than in other MA plans (−0.060) (p=0.002).

Psychiatrist provider networks in a nationwide sample of D-SNPs had similar breadth as psychiatrist networks used in other MA plans. Special provider network adequacy requirements for psychiatrists in D-SNP networks may be worthy of further consideration given D-SNPs’ disproportionate enrollment of adults with serious mental illness who have dual Medicare-Medicaid insurance coverage.