At the September 2023 Components Meeting of the American Psychiatric Association, the APA councils heard reports from their components. Following are summaries of the activities of the councils and their components.
The Council on Addiction Psychiatry
Smita Das, M.D., Ph.D., Chairperson
The Council on Addiction Psychiatry (CAP) is committed to providing psychiatric leadership in the treatment, prevention, and study of substance use disorders (SUDs). The component acts as subject matter experts for the APA around addiction treatment, training, and public policy. To help facilitate collaboration with key stakeholders, the Council frequently invites representatives from the White House Office of National Drug Control Policy (ONDCP), The Drug Enforcement Agency (DEA), The National Institute on Drug Abuse (NIDA), and the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA).
Most prominently, Council members have taken active leadership roles in President Levounis’ workgroup for his presidential initiative; Confronting Addiction, from Prevention to Recovery. The Council on Addiction Psychiatry Chair Dr. Smita Das has worked closely with President Levounis and partners, to guide the work of the initiative. Council Member Dr. Tauheed Zaman has taken lead on efforts around tobacco and vaping, Dr. Lief Fenno on opioid addiction, and Dr. Jeremy Kidd on alcohol misuse.
The Council has focused on increasing access and knowledge around harm reduction resources for substance use disorders, addressing the national opioid crisis, physician training on SUD treatment, increasing access and quality of SUD treatment, and several treatment methods and research opportunities for a variety of SUDs. The Council has helped advise on and develop resources for a variety of key advocacy and regulatory efforts regarding stimulant use disorders, harm reduction, and the national opioid crisis.
The Council provided feedback and recommendations for SAMHSA’s recently released harm reduction framework, as well as the Biden Administration’s framework on smoking cessation, responded with comments to NIDA’s proposal of the introduction of the term “pre-addiction,” and provided insight and practice considerations around the Modernizing Opioid Treatment Access Act.
The Council has been working on several key position statements on addiction psychiatry issues, including a position on contingency management for the treatment of stimulant use disorders, an updated position on opioid overdose education and naloxone distribution in coordination with the American Academy of Addiction Psychiatry (AAAP), and a position statement on harm reduction. These policies and resources are integral in ensuring the APA has strong positions on key addiction psychiatry topics.
The Council has continued to actively collaborate with other APA Councils and external organizations, including the Council on Advocacy and Government Relations, the Council on Consultation Liaison Psychiatry, The Council on Research, The American Society of Addiction Medicine (ASAM), and AAAP.
The Council remains dedicated to improving treatment options, research, and funding for addiction psychiatry efforts.
The Council on Advocacy and Government Relations
Katherine Kennedy, M.D., Chairperson
Federal Affairs
117th congress legislative successes.
In late 2022, the 117th Congress passed legislation advancing numerous APA federal legislative priorities including the following:
Workforce.
Two hundred new Medicare Graduate Medical Education residency slots were funded, with 100 of these slots going directly to psychiatry or psychiatric subspecialties beginning in 2026.
Integration.
Grants to integrate behavioral health with primary care and provide technical assistance to implement the Collaborative Care Model (CoCM).
Health equity.
Reauthorization of the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) Minority Fellowship Program for 5 years as well as an increase in authorized funding for the program.
Telehealth.
Extended several telehealth flexibilities established during the pandemic until 2025, including the delay in the 6-month in-person requirement for telemental health.
Parity.
Authorization of grants to states to enhance enforcement of the Federal parity law.
118th congress.
The APA’s federal legislative agenda includes these priorities:
Telehealth.
APA is working with with Representatives Doris Matsui (D-CA) and Bill Johnson (R-OH) to reintroduce bipartisan legislation that permanently removes the 6-month in-person requirement for telemental health services (H.R. 3432). In addition, APA along with other stakeholders successfully lobbied congressional leaders to include the permanent removal of the 6-month, in-person requirement in the new version of the CONNECT for Health Act (H.R. 4189/S. 2061), which is a comprehensive and bipartisan telehealth bill.
Health equity.
APA spearheaded efforts to identify Congressional co-sponsors and worked closely with Representative Bonnie Watson Coleman (R-NJ) and Senator Robert Menendez (D-NJ) on the reintroduction of the Pursuing Equity in Mental Health Act (H.R. 3548/S. 1700). This legislation would provide increased data collection and funding for integrated care models to build a culturally competent workforce and ensure that youth of color have greater access to mental health services.
Behavioral health integration.
Bipartisan Senate champions introduced S. 1378, the Connecting Our Medical Providers with Links to Expand Tailored and Effective (COMPLETE) Care Act, which is based on an APA-led initiative. The bill would fund technical assistance and temporarily enhance Medicare payment rates for behavioral health integration services (for 3 years) to incentivize primary care to develop and implement integrated care models such as the Collaborative Care Model (CoCM.)
APA Leadership Engagement in Federal Advocacy
APA participates in Group of Six fly-in.
APA President Petros Levounis, M.D., M.A., took part in a Group of Six Leadership (G6) fly-in. During the lobby day, representatives of the six physician organizations (AOA, AAP, ACOG, AAFP, ACP, and APA) met with key House and Senate member and leadership offices to advocate to enact important legislation focused on physician payment, access to mental health care, and increasing the health care workforce.
APA testifies on ghost networks.
APA member Robert Trestman, Ph.D., M.D., Chair of APA’s Council on Health Care Systems Financing, testified before the Senate Finance Committee on the inaccuracies and inequities of ghost networks. His APA testimony and responses to questions from Members of Congress focused on improving directory accuracy, increasing mental health reimbursement rates, addressing workforce shortages, and the impact of expanded telehealth and other policies on rural access to care.
APA participates in congressional briefing.
APA member Smita Das, M.D., Ph.D., MPH, participated in a congressional briefing entitled, “A National Response to a Deadly Crisis: SUPPORT Full-Spectrum Addiction Care.” The briefing, hosted with the House Bipartisan Mental Health and Substance Use Disorder Taskforce and organized by APA and partner organizations, focused on strategies for Congress to address the current opioid and mental health crises.
APA hosts maternal mortality congressional briefing.
APA held a briefing for Congressional staff entitled Maternal Mortality and the Mental Health Crisis. In collaboration with the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG), Maternal Mental Health Leadership Alliance (MMHLA) and Mental Health Liaison Group (MHLG), the panel examined disparities in maternal mental health and potential federal policies to address the crisis. APA members Dr. Nancy Byatt moderated, and Dr. Denis Antoine served as an SUD issue expert. Congresswomen Lauren Underwood and Robin Kelly both participated and spoke on key maternal health legislation.
APA participates in climate congressional briefing.
APA Climate Committee Chair Dr. Joshua Wortzel participated in a virtual briefing discussing the Community Mental Wellness and Resilience Act. The bill authorizes funding for community-led public health approaches to prevent and heal mental health impacts of natural disasters, toxic stresses and environmental emergencies in the age of climate change. Congressional participants included Representatives Paul Tonko (D-NY) and Don Bacon (R-NE).
State Affairs
Legislative activities.
APA has continued to partner with district branches and state psychiatry associations across the country in responding to district branch priority legislation, utilizing the experience of CAGR members where appropriate. In 2023, state-led initiatives included supporting mental health parity, the Psychiatric Collaborative Care Model (CoCM), prior authorization reform, and opposing unsafe prescribing.
Prior authorization.
APA members, including members from CAGR, worked with APA staff to develop legislation to reform the process and eliminate prior authorization for some medications, implement a faster appeals process, and require reviews be conducted by physicians who specialize in the treatment under review. APA has provided this comprehensive prior authorization reform legislation and an advocacy toolkit to all district branches. In 2023, Montana Governor Greg Gianforte signed APA model prior authorization legislation into law. Initiated by the Montana Psychiatric Association, SB 380 prohibits prior authorization in certain circumstances, including for generic prescription drugs, on any drugs that have been prescribed without interruption for 6 months, and on any long-acting injectable medication. The new law also requires that any denial of coverage be made by a physician in the same specialty as the prescriber. Massachusetts and New Jersey are also pursuing APA model prior authorization legislation this year, and other district branches are planning to support similar legislation in 2024.
Parity.
APA previously developed model legislation designed to require transparency and accountability from insurers and state regulators pertaining to compliance with federal MH/SUD parity law as another proactive solution to ameliorate access-to-care problems. APA’s state model parity legislation has been signed into law in nineteen states (Arizona, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Massachusetts, Maryland, Maine, Montana, Nevada, New Jersey, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, West Virginia) and DC. Several other states have enacted partial versions of this law, while Louisiana, Mississippi, and Texas have enforced the parity law through the regulatory process. APA continues to partner with states to help them achieve full parity compliance. This year, CAGR members from several district branches also met with Department of Labor staff to discuss parity implementation in their states.
Psychiatric collaborative care model.
To further increase safe access to effective care, APA developed model Collaborative Care legislation for the states, which would require insurers to cover the codes for the CoCM. CAGR members have been key in promoting this legislation and testifying in states where they are constituents. So far, 10 states (Arkansas, Conneticut, Illinois, Louisiana, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Montana, New Jersey, Oklahoma, and Wyoming) have signed APA’s model bill into law, while Maryland, Nevada, and Texas passed legislation requiring Medicaid to cover the Collaborative Care codes. Arizona, Colorado, North Dakota, Pennsylvania, Texas, and Utah have passed bills allocating grant funding to practices interested in expanding the model. APA is working closely with several district branches interested in pursuing the CoCM in the 2024 legislative session.
Safe prescribing.
While district branches have been able to defeat many unsafe prescribing bills the past few years, 2023 has been challenging. This year, many state legislatures have continued to see legislation from nurse practitioners (NP) and physician assistants (PA) seeking new authorizations to practice without physician involvement, and psychologist prescribing bills were filed in 11 states. APA has worked closely with over 35 district branches this year to oppose unsafe prescribing legislation and CAGR members have provided support to APA staff in the development of talking points, educational comparison charts, and other important data. APA continues to oppose psychologist prescribing and the practice of medicine by psychologists, who lack medical training.
In March 2023, Colorado Governor Jared Polis signed psychologist prescribing legislation into law. APA supported the Colorado Psychiatric Society in opposing the legislation. CPS’s close relationships with many legislators, especially Colorado State Senator Kyle Mullica, produced improvements before the bill passed, including strong physician involvement language and a requirement that prescribing psychologists be subject to education and training standards similar to nurse practitioners and physician assistants. Under the new law, prescribing psychologists must undergo a supervised practicum which must be in person and 1:1 with patients. The practicum must be at least 750 hours long and include seeing at least 150 patients, all under the supervision of a physician. The prescribing psychologist may only prescribe with a collaborative relationship with a physician who oversees the patient’s general medical care. Before prescribing, the prescribing psychologist must communicate to the patient’s primary treating physician the intent to prescribe and must receive an electronic written agreement from the physician that the medication is appropriate. The prescribing psychologist must keep the primary treating physician apprised of all lab tests. The new law also includes Truth in Advertising language to require prescribing psychologists to tell their patients they are not physicians prior to treatment. Prescribing psychologists in the state of Colorado must submit to a peer review process approved by the Colorado Medical Board and carry malpractice insurance of $1 million per claim and $3 million per year. The education and certification standards must also be approved by the Colorado Medical Board. APA staff continue to work with district branches to oppose current and future unsafe prescribing bills.
Committee on advocacy and litigation funding.
As part of APA’s state advocacy efforts, the Committee for Advocacy and Litigation Funding (CALF), chaired by Dr. Patrick Aquino, reviews district branch and state association grant requests for specific public affairs challenges on the state level. Due to limited budgets in many of APA’s district branches and state associations, CALF grants are heavily relied upon by states when confronting new legislative challenges. Once CALF approves an initial request from a district branch or state association, the request is sent to voting members of CAGR to approve, and the Board of Trustees (BOT) makes the final determination to award a grant. Between September 2022 and August 2023, grants were approved for Arizona, Arkansas, Hawaii, Illinois, Montana, New Mexico, Oregon, and South Dakota.
The Council on Children, Adolescents, and Their Families
Anish Dube, M.D., M.P.H., Chairperson
The Council works to maximize the APA’s effectiveness in addressing the mental health needs of children, adolescents, and their families. The Council carries out its charge by developing position statements and resource documents for members and collaborating with other APA Components and allied children’s mental health organizations, including the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatrists. The Committee on Women’s Mental Health, the Caucus on College Mental Health, and the Caucus on Psychiatrists Treating Person with Intellectual Disabilities report to the Council.
In the last year, Council members have worked to respond to several governance referrals related to children’s mental health. They revised the position statement on the endorsement of the United States ratification of the Convention on the Rights of the Child. Members also developed language and pulled together useful resources for physicians in addressing the mental health impact of violence in schools.
Other accomplishments from the group include publishing a resource document on social determinants of mental health in children and youth, identifying social determinants of health that impact child populations, and providing practical tips for providers. The Council also published a resource document addressing the migration emergency and human rights of Haitians, providing historical context, detailed information on the immigration process’ impact on mental health, and recommendation for providers and professional organizations in responding to the immigration crisis. Council members also provided input to the Higher Education Mental Health Alliance Animals on Campus guide, which was published earlier this year.
The Council continues its mentorship program, involving mentors (Council members) being assigned mentees (Council fellows). The pairs review a mentorship guide, outlining expectations and approaches, identify three goals, and sign an agreement to stay connected and meet regularly. Mentors and mentees document their progress quarterly through a survey they fill out. Results are reviewed by the full Council.
The Council’s agenda for the coming year will be divided between four workgroups: Suicide Prevention in Youth, Pediatric Digital Psychiatry, Immigration, and LGBTQIA+
Workgroups are expected to meet outside of the monthly Council calls to develop work products for the group as a whole to review or respond to relevant issues as they arise.
Committee on Women’s Mental Health
Aside from its continued work on governance referrals, Committee members have spent the past few months working on several projects. Members collaborated with the Committee on Telepsychiatry to finalize a resource document on telehealth services in the context of intimate partner violence. Several members of the Committee are working on APA’s CDC grant on identifying and addressing treatment and training gaps in perinatal mental health care. Dr. DeFaria, the Committee’s Chairperson, is serving as Vice Chair of the grant workgroup.
The U.S. Supreme Court’s Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization decision to overturn Roe v. Wade shaped much of the Committee’s work, including several Psychiatric News articles and joining a cross-component workgroup led by the Council on Psychiatry and the Law. The group plans on addressing considerations for psychiatrists in the post-Roe landscape.
Finally, the Committee is continuing to serve as APA’s expert group on women’s mental health. Members worked with staff in submitting comments to the U.S. Preventative Services Task Force’s Guidelines for Screening for Anxiety in Adults and Screening for Depression and Suicide Risk. The group also reviewed two sets of clinical practice guidelines from the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists on Screening and Diagnosis of Mental Health Conditions During Pregnancy and Postpartum and Psychopharmacologic Treatment and Management of Mental Health Disorders During Pregnancy and Postpartum.
The Council on Communications
Isabel Norian, M.D., Chairperson
Since the APA Annual Meeting, the Council on Communications members have received updates from APA staff on several topics, including the search for a new Editor-in-Chief at Psychiatric News, sign-up information for the APA Internal Speaker’s Bureau, and an upcoming series of media trainings led by Communications Division staff that will be held on a bi-monthly basis for APA members.
Communications Division staff have presented to the Council on Dr. Petros Levounis’ theme for his presidential year, “Confronting Addiction from Prevention to Recovery.” The Council has been active in supporting this ongoing initiative on social media and in offering feedback on certain materials and strategies for amplifying the message of each of the quarterly campaigns.
Council members provided constructive feedback to representatives from Finn Partners regarding the Mental Health Care Works Campaign developed with APA and APAF. Council members gave feedback on the direction of the campaign from a clinical perspective and were overall very positive about the campaign and its message. Since the campaign launch in August, Council members have been active in sharing and signal-boosting campaign materials online and in the regions the campaign is currently active in (DC/Baltimore, Raleigh, and Detroit).
Dr. Will Wong presented on the toolkit he co-authored entitled Mental Health Toll of Anti-AAPI Hate and Violence: An APA Press Kit on Reporting on Racism and Health. This toolkit is intended to be used by the media and journalists who are covering issues related to AAPI hate and violence in both entertainment and news media. Council members have provided feedback to Communications Division Staff and the authors offline in the weeks since the presentation.
The Council continues to support APA Communications initiatives on an ongoing through social media engagement and signal boosting, and by providing constructive feedback to Communications Division staff when it is requested. Council members continue to assist in content review and development for APA’s Spanish-language site
Lasaludmental.org.
The Council is currently discussing strategies to combat misinformation on social media platforms, especially TikTok, and also engaging with their assigned fellows to strategize on how to best reach Gen Z and younger generations with evidence-based information on mental health that is accessible and relatable.
The Council on Consultation-Liaison Psychiatry
Maria Tiamson-Kassab, M.D., Chairperson
The Council on Consultation Liaison Psychiatry is focused on the psychiatric care of persons who have medical, surgical, and obstetrical conditions, with C-L psychiatrists providing integrated care for individuals with co-occurring acute and chronic illness. C-L psychiatry has remained essential for treating comorbid psychiatric and physical conditions, and with continued increases in integrated care, the Council serves as a crucial resource to the APA for navigating this space.
The Council has continued its work on a series of Consultation-Liaison Psychiatry Psychiatric News articles, which include recent pieces on transgender care, end-of-life care, social justice, and opioid use disorder treatment
The Council, in collaboration with the Academy of Consultation-Liaison Psychiatry, hosted a webinar titled “Applying to C-L Psychiatry Fellowships in 2023: a Virtual Q&A!” on June 4, 2023. The webinar had an audience of over 100 participants.
In addition to the efforts above, the Council is developing a resource document on acute and long COVID-19, and is assisting in the development of the Pain Management Caucus’ creation of a pain management and education resource document. The Council has also discussed and begun the process of developing resource documents from previous Psychiatric News articles, which would provide an opportunity to expand on the key areas of interest addressed in these works.
Consultation Liaison Psychiatry remains a critical area of psychiatric focus in a time when integrated models of care are becoming increasingly utilized. This Council remains committed to steering APA in the right direction on consultation-liaison psychiatry-related issues, and looks forward to future opportunities to expand on their work.
The Council on Geriatric Psychiatry
Daniel C. Dahl, M.D., Chairperson
The Council supports the APA in its work on behalf of older adults and the psychiatrists who care for them. To this end, the Council develops position statements and resource documents on essential issues in geriatric psychiatry, thereby providing APA with background information critical for advocacy efforts and interactions with the media. The Council also collaborates with other professional groups to develop best practices in geriatric psychiatry, promote research, and provide education and training to psychiatrists, other physicians, residents, medical students, and allied mental health professionals.
Position Statements
In collaboration with the Council on Addictions, the Council has submitted an extensive revision of the position statement on substance use in older adults.
The Council was tasked to review and provide input on the existing position statement on the role of psychiatrists in assessing driving ability to determine if it should be retained, revised, or retired. After a thorough review of the document, and in consultation with several other councils—Ethics, Psychiatry and the Law, Quality Care, Government Relations and Advocacy, and legal counsel—the Council agreed to recommend that the statement be retired. However, the Board of Trustees still finds value in psychiatrists assessing driving ability, so a new position was submitted for JRC review.
The Council reviewed the elder abuse, neglect and exploitation position statement and voted to retain the statement as is and will submit the position to the JRC.
The Council reviewed the role of psychiatrists in palliative care and made several recommendations that will be submitted to the JRC.
The Council is also reviewing the position statement on judicious use of antipsychotics in major neurocognitive disorder related agitation considering the FDA approval of brexpiprazole for the treatment of agitation associated with dementia due to Alzheimer’s disease.
Publications and presentations.
A Council member co-wrote several articles about the importance of good dental care and mental health and slowing dementia in Psychiatric News, “Interactions between Dental Care and Mental Health Care in Promoting Health and Longevity.”
At the APA Annual Meeting, the Council sponsored several sessions including “Social Media for Seniors: Pros, Cons and Scams,” as well as “Identifying Ageism: Moving Toward Addressing Gaps in Mental Health Care for Older Adults.”
The council presented a webinar on the management of behavioral disturbances and dementia in the nursing home and an APA blog on thriving in old age.
DSM criteria for neurocognitive disorders.
The Council met with the DSM Steering Committee to review changes to criteria for neurocognitive disorders to better reflect clinical practice. The Council concurred with the proposed changes.
Appropriate use of antipsychotics in nursing homes.
The Council is actively discussing this issue considering the CMS audit of nursing homes which found a high rate of new onset schizophrenia diagnoses in nursing home patients on antipsychotics. The Council is working with the AAGP to consider appropriate actions.
Appropriate use of antidepressants in long-term care.
Members of the Council voiced concerns regarding a recent article published in Annals of Long-Term Care that advocated for abrupt discontinuation of antidepressants in that setting, with very short term follow up. Several Council members continue to work on a review article to serve as guidance for clinicians to assess antidepressant use in long-term care, make determinations as to when it is appropriate to discontinue these medications, and offer recommendations on gradual reductions, as well as long-term follow-up to quickly identify recurrent depressive symptoms.
APA legislative update.
The Council is grateful that the APA has been and remains a strong advocate for continued insurance and Medicare coverage to expand access to care for elderly Americans in need of mental health treatment. The APA was involved in the Consolidated Appropriation Act which created 100 additional Graduate Medical Education slots for psychiatry and its subspecialties. The APA is pursuing debt reduction for those pursuing a Geriatric Psychiatry Fellowship. Collaborative care is also a focus with additional funding.
AAN geriatric neurology standing measure development workgroup.
Dr. Nash is representing the Council and the APA as this workgroup updates the dementia quality measures.
Other projects.
The Council is actively reviewing information about the mental health of senior refugees and asylum seekers and considering the best way to present the information.
Council of geriatric psychiatry awards.
The Harford-Jeste Award was presented to Dr. Rajaram Manoharan and the Jack Weinberg Award to Dr. Shilpa Srinivasan at APA Annual Meeting during the session “A Clinician’s Guide to the Management of Behavioral and Psychological Symptoms of Dementia in the Era of Boxed Warnings.”
The Council on Healthcare Systems and Financing
Robert Trestman, Ph.D., M.D., Chairperson
The Council on Health care Systems and Financing (CHSF) continues its efforts to monitor and provide analysis on a number of significant issues that impact the financing, delivery of, and access to psychiatric care. These efforts include outreach to decision makers in both the public and private sectors. Council members provide guidance on APA’s responses to the Administration on health care reform, quality, and payment reform.
The Council has continued reviewing and revising existing APA policies referred to them by the Joint Reference Committee, as well as addressing concerns raised by the Assembly action paper process. This includes revising the position statement on the use of jails to hold persons without criminal charges who are awaiting civil psychiatric hospital beds, as well as the position statement on remuneration for psychiatrists’ time performing utilization review. Council members also reviewed the position statement on peer support services.
Building off their Chair roundtable in 2022, CHSF and the Council on Quality Care hosted a joint meeting in San Francisco to discuss various aspects of the Presidential Work Group on the Future of Psychiatry’s report which could be relevant to their work. Drs. Trestman and Alter, the Council Chairs who were involved in the Presidential Workgroup, walked members through the report. The group also discussed potential areas of collaboration and plan to meet biannually to maintain open lines of communication on initiatives relevant to both Councils.
The Council oversees the work of three Committees: Committee on Integrated Care, Committee on RBRVS, and Committee on Reimbursement for Psychiatric Care. Each of these groups collaborate with the Council on projects, while also furthering their respective agendas.
Committee on Integrated Care
Shannon Kinnan, M.D., Chairperson
The Committee on Integrated Care updated the position statement on the role of psychiatrists in reducing physical health disparities in patients with mental illness which was approved by the APA Joint Reference Committee in July. The Committee has established two workgroups that will develop resources for APA members related to the integration of physical and medical care, as well as development of patient-facing information related to integrated/coordinated/collaborative care.
Committee on RBRVS, Codes and Reimbursement
Jeremy Musher, M.D., Chairperson
The Committee continues to provide educational resources on how to properly code and document services. This includes a well-attended webinar in December, articles in Psychiatric News and a session at the APA Annual Meeting in San Francisco. The group also provides support to the Practice Management Helpline by responding to CPT coding and documentation queries. Members have provided input to APA’s advocacy efforts with CMS regarding pay parity for psychiatric services including services provided by telehealth. The Committee has new representation on the AMA reimbursement related committees—the AMA CPT Editorial Panel and the AMA/Specialty Society RVS Update Committee (RUC); members will continue to advise and advocate on behalf of psychiatry in those roles.
Committee on Reimbursement for Psychiatric Care
Laurence Miller, M.D., Chairperson
Members of the Committee provided input to APA’s advocacy efforts regarding payment for evidence-based mental health care including sustainable funding for 988 services, and payment for coordinated specialty care (CSC). They have also provided input on APA’s advocacy efforts on MIPS Episode-Based Cost measures, as well as APA’s comments related to Medicaid, Medicare Advantage plans and Inpatient reimbursement rates among others.
The Council on International Psychiatry and Global Health
Pamela Collins, M.D., M.P.H., Chairperson
The Council on International Psychiatry and Global Health (Council) facilitates understanding of problems facing international psychiatrists and their patients. The Council brings to the mission of the APA the global perspectives of individual, family, culture, and population-based approaches for understanding mental health well-being and the treatment and prevention of psychiatric illnesses. It coordinates with the APA Caucus on Global Mental Health and Psychiatry (Caucus) on relevant activities and the APA Office of International Affairs. The Council Chair is Dr. Pamela Collins and the Caucus Chair is Dr. Rahn Bailey.
Migration and Mental Health
The Council established a Cross-Council Workgroup on Migration Emergencies in response to APA efforts to support psychiatrists and mental health professionals as they come face-to-face with an increasing number of individuals and families experiencing forced displacement due to conflict, violence, human rights issues, and climate change. The workgroup is co-led by Dr. Pamela Collins and Dr. Badr Ratnakaran, with support from Ricardo Juarez and the APA Office of International Affairs and is comprised of 18 representatives from six different APA Councils and components. The Council and workgroup received feedback and support from organizations during initial discussion around this topic including the National Institute of Mental Health, the Royal College of Psychiatrists, and the World Psychiatric Association, as well as guidance from the APA Joint Reference Committee. The workgroup is focused on developing a resource document on the mental health response to migration emergencies which intends to provide guidance on understanding the full migration experience across the lifespan, considerations for delivering treatment and care to individuals and families, the nuances of access to services, the impact of migration on marginalized groups, and how to support resettlement efforts. In addition to existing APA resources providing guidance on delivering culturally competent care to immigrants, refugees, and asylees, the workgroup is also identifying practical tools and resources for emergency settings from the World Health Organization and relevant United Nations agencies such as the UN Refugee Agency, the International Organization for Migration, and U.S. agencies such as the HHS Office of Refugee Resettlement and SAMHSA.
Global Mental Health Education and Training
At the 2023 APA Annual Meeting, the Council met to discuss initiatives to support global mental health education and training and identify groups for coordination and collaboration on resource development. The Council connected with the APA Caucus on Global Mental Health and Psychiatry which established a Work Group on Global Mental Health Curriculum comprised of Dr. Kenneth Fung, Dr. Seeba Anum, Dr. Victor Pereira-Sanchez, and Dr. Rick Wolthusen. Over the past year, the workgroup reviewed and discussed the APA resource document on developing a global mental health curriculum in psychiatry residency programs, solicited input and feedback at the 2023 American Association of Directors of Psychiatric Residency Training (AADPRT) Annual Meeting and presented their findings at the 2023 APA Annual Meeting. The Council also met with Dr. Anna E. Ordóñez, Director of the Office of Clinical Research at the National Institute of Mental Health on “reciprocal learning,” which has become the basis for the Fogarty Center for Global Health Studies Global Health Reciprocal Innovation project, focused on identifying mutually beneficial research models in diverse settings and exploring promising models of research funding. The Council continues to work closely with the Caucus to collaborate on these efforts and identify next steps in the development of a model curriculum, supporting global partnership and exchange, exploring the intersection between global mental health and community mental health, and addressing barriers and challenges.
Misuse of Psychiatry and Human Rights
The Council continues to review and update position statements that address the misuse and abuse of psychiatry and human rights violations. Over the past year, the Council updated the APA position statement on human rights which was approved by the Assembly and the Board of Trustees and is currently reviewing and updating the APA position statement on the use of psychiatric institutions for the commitment of political dissenters. These position statements are utilized by the APA to respond to cases of the misuse and abuse of psychiatry and human rights violations.
Action Projects
The Council has focused on identifying action projects for the Council’s resident-fellows and early career psychiatrists to participate in and complete during their time on the Council. These opportunities also serve as an opportunity for them to connect with other Council members who have experience and expertise in their interests to provide mentorship and sponsorship when possible. The following are the action projects for the past year:
•
Psychiatric Services journal submissions
•
JRC Workgroup on IMG Members and Members of International Origin
•
Cross-Council Workgroup on Migration and Mental Health
•
Council Workgroup on the Misuse of Psychiatric Institutions
•
International Research Engagement Program
The Council on Medical Education and Lifelong Learning
Art Walaszek, M.D., Chairperson
The Council on Medical Education and Lifelong Learning (CMELL) monitors emerging issues in psychiatry education and facilitates the development of education resources and programs. The purview of the Council includes medical education, graduate medical education for residents and fellows in psychiatry, psychiatric aspects of graduate medical education for other medical specialists and continuing medical education and lifelong learning. The Council acts in an advisory role to the APA Division of Education in the development of continuing education programs and initiatives. Some of the recent matters on which the Council has recently worked are:
Impact of COVID on Psychiatric Education
The council formed a work group to survey the effects of the pandemic on psychiatric education. Led by former chair, Dr. Eindra Khin Khin, the workgroup has produced a manuscript that will be published in an upcoming edition of Psychiatric News.
Collaborators: Eindra Khin Khin, M.D., Marshall Forstein, M.D., Erick Hung, M.D., Ana Ozdoba, M.D., Mary Vance, M.D., Kevin Ing, M.D., Nancy Rodriguez, M.D.
AAMC Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Competencies Across the Learning Continuum
As part of our council’s strategic plan to help incorporate DEI into psychiatric education, we formed a workgroup to review the AAMC DEI competencies and to make recommendations for how these could be applied to APA’s educational offerings. The workgroup has made recommendations which will be shared with the APA Division of Education.
Collaborators: Theadia Carey, M.D., Brigitte Bailey, M.D., Fíona Fonseca, M.D.
APA Educational Awards
The council annually reviews nominations for APA educational awards: Vestermark Psychiatric Educator Award, Irma Bland Award for Excellence in Teaching Residents, and Nancy Roeske Certificate of Recognition for Excellence in Medical Student Education. The council has selected the Vestermark winner and is reviewing Irma Bland and Nancy Roeske nominees.
Collaborators: all members of CMELL and the members of the Vestermark Award Committee: Donna Sudak, M.D. (Chair), Greg Briscoe, M.D., Sadé Frazier, D.O.
Position Statements
The council reviewed and provided feedback on three position statements that were initially published in 2018:
•
Residency Training Needs in Addiction Psychiatry for the General Psychiatrist
•
Consistent Treatment of All Applicants for State Medical Licensure
•
Neuroscience Training in Psychiatry Residency Training
The council has also been asked to draft a position statement on academic freedom. A work group has started on this, with an anticipated draft by mid-October. We will seek consultation from the Council on Minority Mental Health and Health Disparities.
Collaborators: all members of CMELL
The Council on Minority Mental Health and Health Disparities
Walter Wilson, M.D., Chairperson
Position Statement on Homelessness and Mental Health Support
The Council on Minority Mental Health and Health Disparities took pride in its active role in reviewing and supporting the position statement on homelessness and mental health put forth by the Council on Advocacy and Government Relations (CAGR). This collaborative effort underscores our commitment to addressing the critical intersection of mental health and homelessness. By endorsing this statement, we contribute to the recognition of homelessness as a complex challenge exacerbated by mental health disparities. Our support signifies the imperative to advocate for policy changes, resource allocation, and interventions that offer comprehensive mental health support to individuals experiencing homelessness. Through this position statement, we strive to foster societal awareness, sensitivity, and compassionate action to ensure equitable mental health care access for all, irrespective of their housing status.
Mental Health Equity Fireside Chat: Transgender Mental Health
In our continuous pursuit of mental health equity, the Council embarked on creating a significant platform through a Mental Health Equity Fireside Chat focused on transgender mental health. This endeavor underscores our recognition of the unique challenges faced by transgender individuals in accessing quality mental health care. By fostering dialog and sharing insights from experts and lived experiences, we aimed to promote understanding, dispel stigma, and pave the way for inclusive mental health practices. This Fireside Chat served as a catalyst for meaningful change, shedding light on the importance of affirming and culturally competent mental health care for transgender individuals.
Revising Position Statement on Affirmative Action
Recognizing the ongoing need for equal access and opportunities, the Council has undertaken the crucial task of revising the APA’s position statement on affirmative action. Our commitment to diversity, equity, and inclusion drives this effort, as we work to ensure that the statement reflects the evolving landscape of affirmative action and its impact on mental health disparities. By advocating for fair and inclusive practices in education and employment, we aim to address systemic barriers and create pathways to success for underrepresented communities. This endeavor reflects our dedication to dismantling structural inequalities that affect mental health outcomes.
Revising Position Statement on Discrimination Against International Medical Graduates
The Council's commitment to helping advance global mental health equity is evident in our ongoing efforts to revise the position statement on discrimination against international medical graduates. By addressing discrimination faced by international medical graduates, we acknowledge the vital contributions they make to mental health care and research. Our advocacy seeks to create an inclusive environment that values diverse expertise and perspectives, fostering collaboration and innovation in the field. Through this revision, we aim to promote cultural competence, eliminate bias, and uphold the principles of fairness and equity in the treatment of international medical graduates.
Participation in Workgroup to Create an APA Perinatal Mental Health Toolkit
Our dedication to comprehensive mental health care extends to the perinatal period. The Council's active involvement in a workgroup focused on creating a Perinatal Mental Health Toolkit demonstrates our commitment to supporting individuals considering pregnancy, currently pregnant, or postpartum, as well as practitioners. By compiling resources, facts, and culturally sensitive information, we assisted in creating a valuable guide that addresses the unique mental health challenges faced during this critical life phase. This toolkit reinforces our goal of eliminating disparities and ensuring that mental health resources are readily accessible to all, contributing to the well-being of both individuals and their communities.
Collaboration With Ethics Committee: Diversity and Inclusion in Medical Ethics
The Council's collaboration with the Ethics Committee highlights our dedication to embedding diversity, equity, and inclusion in the very fabric of medical ethics. By contributing to the modification of opinions on principles of medical ethics through a lens of diversity, we promote ethical practices that reflect the values of an inclusive society. This collaborative effort underscores our commitment to ensuring that ethical considerations are culturally sensitive, just, and respectful of the diverse backgrounds and perspectives of patients and practitioners alike.
Revising and Updating APA Position Statements
As part of our ongoing commitment to addressing mental health disparities, the Council is engaged in a comprehensive effort to revise and update APA’s position statements addressing crucial topics including discrimination against transgender and gender diverse individuals, racism and its impact on mental health, religious persecution and genocide, conversion therapy and LGBTQ patients, discrimination against religious minorities, human trafficking, mental health equity and the social and structural determinants of mental health, and police brutality and Black males. Through these revisions, we aim to create a comprehensive framework that reflects the diverse experiences and needs of those we serve. Through these revisions, we seek to establish the American Psychiatric Association as a beacon of inclusivity, advocacy, and equity, striving to eliminate disparities and improve mental health outcomes for all.
Each of these endeavors underscores our dedication to advancing mental health equity, promoting diversity, and eliminating disparities within our field. Through collaboration, advocacy, and continuous dialog, we aim to create a future where mental health care is accessible, inclusive, and effective for all individuals, regardless of their background or circumstances.
Council on Psychiatry and the Law
Richard Martinez, M.D., Chairperson
The Council on Psychiatry and Law is responsible for evaluating legal developments of national significance that affect the practice of psychiatry and the availability and quality of mental health care, including case law, legislation, and all other forms of legal regulation of psychiatric practice. It includes a focus on practice areas such as correctional psychiatry, the interface of addictions and the law, child and adolescent psychiatry, and the subspecialty of forensic psychiatry. In the past year, the Council has worked on a wide variety of issues. This report highlights some of the topics covered from 2022-2023.
Telepsychiatry for Adults in Jails and Prisons
The workgroup on correctional psychiatry is chaired by Dr. Elizabeth Ford and is tasked with leading the Council’s efforts to focus on issues within correctional psychiatry. The workgroup published the Resource Document on Telepsychiatry for Adults in Jails and Prisons to be used as a guide for psychiatrists interested in or already working with adults who are incarcerated in jails or prisons and for whom telepsychiatry is a current or potential clinical practice. This resource document may also be helpful for psychiatric administrators in correctional facilities who are considering the implementation of telepsychiatry. The resource document includes clinical vignettes and sections on levels of mental health care, general and specific clinical considerations, and administrative considerations. The resource document was approved by the Joint Reference Committee in February 2023 and is available at
https://www.psychiatry.org/Psychiatrists/Search-Directories-Databases/Resource-Documents/2023/Telepsychiatry-for-Adults-in-Jails-and-Prisons-1.
Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization
Drs. Renee Binder (Council on Psychiatry and Law) and Madeleine Becker (Council on Consultation Liaison Psychiatry and Committee on Women’s Mental Health) co-chair this workgroup to examine issues surrounding the impact of the Dobbs v. Jackson Supreme Court decision, which overturned Roe v. Wade, on the field of psychiatry. The workgroup drafted a report on the effects of Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization on mental health and the physician-patient relationship, a document that outlines the implications of Dobbs for psychiatrists to help states in their advocacy efforts against restrictive abortion laws. The workgroup is collaborating with Psych News to publish this report. The workgroup is also drafting a resource document on clinical challenges that psychiatrists may face in the aftermath of this Supreme Court decision. Additionally, the workgroup assisted in the revision of existing position statements on abortion. The workgroup also includes members of the Ethics Committee; Council on Children, Adolescents, and Their Families; Council on Consultation-Liaison Psychiatry; and Committee on Women’s Mental Health.
Addressing Discriminatory Policies That Prevent Access to Housing and Employment
Despite some legal safeguards, individuals with psychiatric illness, especially those with past criminal behavior related to their psychiatric illness, are vulnerable to legal and illegal discrimination that prevents access to housing and employment and worsens symptomatology. Dr. Connor Darby led a workgroup to develop a position statement that urges the repeal of laws and policies that prevent or impede access to housing and employment for persons with mental disorders (unless there are overriding considerations) and supports laws and policies that provide protections for persons with mental disorders to access housing and employment. This position statement was approved by the Board of Trustees in July 2023 and is available at
https://www.psychiatry.org/getattachment/543fdf0e-4665-426e-9e09-e7512fcc0997/Position-Discriminatory-Policies-Housing-and-Employment.pdf.
5-Year Review of Position Statements
The following position statements were reviewed by the Council as part of the 5-year review process and have been approved by the Board of Trustees:
•
Health Care, approved in December 2022
•
Misuse of Psychiatric Examinations and Disclosure of Psychiatric Records in Sexual Harassment Litigation, approved in December 2022
•
Restrictive Housing of Incarcerated Adults with Serious Mental Illness, approved in July 2023
•
Lengthy Sentences Without Parole for Juveniles, approved in July 2023
•
Assessing the Risk for Violence, approved in July 2023
Committee on Judicial Action
Reena Kapoor, M.D., Chairperson
The Committee on Judicial Action is a component of the Council that considers and recommends APA involvement as a friend of the court in cases at every level of the judicial system and covering a range of issues. Since the 2022 Council Report, APA has joined briefs in the following cases:
•
K.C. et al., v. Individual Members of the Medical Licensing Board of Indiana, et al., opposing legislation in Indiana that bans healthcare providers from providing patients under 18 with treatment for gender dysphoria.
•
L.W. et al., v. Jonathan Skrmetti, et al., opposing legislation in Kentucky and Tennessee that bans healthcare providers from providing patients under 18 with treatment for gender dysphoria.
•
Braidwood Management, Inc. et al., v. Xavier Becerra, opposing the disruption of the Affordable Care Act’s requirement that certain preventive services be provided at no cost to the patient.
•
August Dekker, et al., v. Jason Weida, et al., opposing Florida’s ban on Medicaid reimbursement for the treatment of patients with gender dysphoria.
•
Christopher Fain; Shauntae Anderson v. William Crouch et al., opposing West Virginia’s decision to bar coverage of gender-affirming care for state employees and their dependents.
•
Maxwell Kadel, et al. v. Dale Folwell, et al., opposing North Carolina’s decision to bar coverage of gender-affirming care for state employees and their dependents.
•
Pacira Biosciences, Inc., v. American Society Of Anesthesiologists, Inc., et al., arguing that First Amendment protection for debate about scientific conclusions is essential to the development of safe and effective medicine.
•
Greg Abbott, et al. v. Jane Doe, et al., opposing enforcement of the Abbott Letter, which directed the Texas Department of Family Protective Services to determine whether some gender confirmation surgeries for transgender children constitute child abuse under existing state law.
Additionally, the Committee wrote its own briefs in the following cases:
•
David Wit, et al. v. United Behavioral Health, Gary Alexander, et al. v. United Behavioral Health, challenging the use of inappropriately restrictive guidelines by private insurance companies when reviewing claims for behavioral health treatment.
•
Michelle Himes v. Somatics, LLC to explain the legitimate clinical use of electroconvulsive therapy.
•
DiNardo a v. Chistian Kohler, M.D, et al., to support the importance of the Pennsylvania law that prevents recovery for felonious acts.
Other Topics
The Council continues to work on an array of topics, including mass incarceration, residency education on correctional psychiatry, restrictions on patient access to personal items while psychiatrically hospitalized, bias and capacity of law enforcement personnel, firearms access, and issues pertaining to the 25th Amendment. Additionally, the Council frequently cross-collaborates with other APA components, including the Councils on Addiction Psychiatry, Mental Health and Health Disparities, Quality Care, Advocacy and Government Relations, Children, Adolescents and their Families, and Research, as well as the Committees on Telepsychiatry, Women’s Mental Health, and the Ethics Committee. The Isaac Ray Award Committee and Manfred S. Guttmacher Award Committee each report to the Council. The Isaac Ray Award recognizes a person who has made outstanding contributions to forensic psychiatry or the psychiatric aspects of jurisprudence; it was awarded to Dr. Steven (Ken) Hoge in 2023. The Manfred S. Guttmacher Award recognizes an outstanding contribution to the literature of forensic psychiatry; it was awarded to Drs. Donald W. Black and Nathan J. Kolla for their book, the Textbook of Antisocial Personality Disorder. Both committees are in the process of selecting 2024 award recipients. Additionally, the Council on Psychiatry and Law and Committee on Judicial Action will hold a joint session in September focused on firearms and mental illness.
The Council on Quality Care
Carol Alter, M.D., Chairperson
The Council on Quality Care’s overarching goal is to ensure the highest standards of care remain an integral part of APA’s mission. To achieve this goal, the Council on Quality Care (hereafter referred to as “Council”) monitors advances, carries out activities, and disseminates information related to, but not limited to, the following areas: clinical practice guidelines; quality measures and performance indicators; implementation of patient registries; standards and survey procedures; clinical informatics that leverage health information technologies to improve care; and patient safety. The Council collaborates with other groups within APA’s governance structure to respond to topics of mutual concern, such as quality measures, accreditation standards, and the effects of quality improvement efforts on clinical practice, individual patient outcomes, and general population health. This includes collaborating with the Council on Health care Systems and Financing to identify and coordinate efforts on topic areas of mutual interest.
Committees on Telepsychiatry and Mental Health IT
The Committees on Telepsychiatry, chaired by Dr. Shabana Khan, and Mental Health Information Technology, chaired by Dr. Darlene King, meet jointly to work together where there is overlap in digital health policy and practice.
This year, the Committee on Telepsychiatry was moved under the Council on Quality Care alongside the Committee on Telepsychiatry. The two Committees have delivered education for APA members on how telepractice looks now that the COVID-19 public health emergency (PHE) has ended; along with written materials, the Committee chairs co-presented webinars in January and April 2023 along with additional member education and support activities. The two Committees also worked together to deliver digital health and telepsychiatry sessions for the 2023 Annual Meeting, including presenting a Learning Lab and a Member Forum on telepsychiatry. The Committees have jointly informed APA policy efforts around technology-enabled care, including comments to the Drug Enforcement Agency (DEA) about telemedicine prescribing of controlled substances, letters to the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) and Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) about mental health data-sharing and interoperability, and feedback to CMS about access to telemental health in the Medicare program. The Committees are also collaborating closely on member education and frameworks around the appropriate integration of AI into psychiatric practice.
Committee on Mental Health IT
The Committee has developed position statements and resources to address emerging needs in mental health technology. This includes a new position statement, “Promoting Health and Protecting Populations from Social Media and Online Harms.” The intent of this position statement is to equip APA to advocate for policies that protect patients from harm while adopting elements of technology that improve care and outcomes. The Committee also developed and published “Digital Mental Health 101,” a resource document about mobile health and technology-enabled care which can be found here. The Committee has also been active in responding to recent federal rulemaking, developing comments on a proposed national provider directory, substance use disorder data protections, and interoperability and electronic prior authorizations.
Committee on Telepsychiatry
The Committee has worked to support APA members in telehealth and hybrid practice after the PHE ends. This included publishing “Best Practices in Synchronous Videoconferencing-Based Telemental Health,” an update to a previous document created in collaboration with the American Telemedicine Association with the intent to provide a single guide on clinical best practices for providing mental health services via synchronous videoconferencing. The Committee also informed an APA survey to assess telepractice across membership to guide APA’s ongoing efforts to advocate for policies that support telepsychiatry and access to care. The Committee has also been active in responding in responding to recent federal rulemaking, developing comments on proposed regulations around virtual prescribing of controlled substances, reimbursement for telepsychiatry, and rules regarding virtual supervision of resident physicians.
Committee on Practice Guidelines
APA was awarded a $100,000 grant from the Council of Medical Specialty Societies (CMSS) to promote the early and proper diagnosis of eating disorders. The grant, funded by the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation, is being used to develop products derived from the approved APA practice guideline on the treatment of eating disorders that will educate psychiatrists, primary care providers, and patients and caregivers in the importance of diagnosing eating disorders early and accurately. The final version of the guideline and a variety of derivative products including a new decision support tool, clinician and patient guides, and CME activities are available at
psychiatry.org/guidelines. You can access the clinical decision support tool directly here:
https://live.avomd.io/dashboard/8506c158-349e-41e6.
The guideline on borderline personality disorder writing group chaired by Dr. George Keepers, finished public comment June 23. We received feedback from 24 organizations and 20 individuals, which is being reviewed and incorporated into the draft, as appropriate. The draft will be sent for approval by the Assembly and then the Board of Trustees in September. The delirium writing group, chaired by Dr. Cathy Crone is reviewing draft text in preparation for public comment in September. The bipolar disorder writing group, chaired by Dr. Victor Reus, will kick off in the autumn once the results from the expert survey have been analyzed.
The systematic review for generalized anxiety disorder is being updated and a writing group will begin work in late fall. The 2023 budget was approved to develop a systematic review based on the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs’ review for major depressive disorder but focused on treatment resistant depression. Contracting with an evidence-based practice center will begin soon. Updates on the use of antipsychotics in patients with dementia and agitation or psychosis as well as alcohol use disorder are in development.
The Committee also reviews other guidelines and materials for inclusion on the web page and has three VA guidelines and one ASAM guideline as well as several resource documents posted. We will continue to review other materials that may be appropriate. If you know of a practice guideline or other document you think would be helpful for APA membership, please send information to
[email protected].
Committee on Quality and Performance Measurement
The Committee on Quality and Performance Measurement (CQPM) continues to review measures made available for comment by national organizations. In the fall, the Committee reviewed a CMS’ MIPS Value Pathway (MVP) proposal for MH/SUD care and submitted comments to NQF on several measures moving forward for consideration in the CMS MIPS program, including measures APA developed as part of the CMS Cooperative Agreement.
In the spring, the committee submitted public comments regarding measures related to the diagnosis and management of insomnia, that are currently being revised by the American Academy of Sleep Medicine. Members also support the work of APA’s representative to the CMS/AHIP Core Quality Measure Collaborative and reviewed the measures proposed for the CHIP Core Set. The committee discussed the new proposed measures on Social Drivers of Health in the Inpatient Psychiatric Facility rule. Currently, the committee is refining measure specifications for the development of measurement-based care process measures to encourage the measurement of progress over time. The committee is also in the process of reviewing the more final proposed version of the MVP in the draft Physician Fee Schedule Proposed Rule, and responding to other pieces related to behavioral health, with comments due 9/11.
Reporting Workgroups and Other Work With Member-Experts
The Council oversees the work of the following workgroups:
Patient safety workgroup.
This workgroup, chaired by Dr. Jacqueline Hobbs, has been creating collateral materials to highlight the APA resource document on seclusion or restraint, including a blog post, and an educational webinar. There has been a lot of interest among members regarding potential bias (e.g., racial, ethnic, etc.) in the use of seclusion or restraint. Data and experiences from various institutions and populations have been reviewed. This topic was part of the discussion during the workgroup’s annual meeting presentation and will be included in future educational webinars. There are plans for the development of an article for submission to a relevant publication. Other areas of interest for the group are standardized safety huddles, patient safety dashboards, and risk adjustment.
Workgroup on implementation of measurement-based care (MBC).
The workgroup, chaired by Drs. Kathryn Ridout and Erik Vanderlip, developed a resource document that focuses on implementing MBC in solo or small practices. It covers topics such as implementation, technology, and reimbursement, along with challenges and solutions. The resource document was approved by the JRC in June 2023. Members of the workgroup have presented this topic at APA’s educational meetings, the APA Annual Meeting and the Mental Health Services Conference.
Technical advisors.
Members of the Council on Quality Care, with support from its component groups, continue to serve in leadership and advisory roles with the Core Quality Measures Collaborative. APA has nominated individuals to serve on relevant committees convened by the new Partnership for Quality Measurement, under Battelle, the new consensus-based entity, replacing the National Quality Forum. These multi-stakeholder panels are responsible for defining national quality measurement strategies, developing meaningful quality measurement tools, recommending appropriate use of quality measures and how institutions will be surveyed for behavioral health care. These appointments afford the APA an authoritative voice in the national quality enterprise.
The Council on Research
Jonathan Alpert, M.D., Ph.D., Chairperson
The Council on Research continues to help ensure that research on mental health remains integral to the American Psychiatric Association’s mission and in the forefront of the national health agenda. The Council embodies APA’s commitment to advance psychiatric knowledge through the conduct of research by physician scientists and the training of diverse early career psychiatry researchers across a broad range of areas including basic and translational science, clinical diagnosis and assessment, therapeutics, epidemiology, health services, and computational psychiatry. These areas are represented by the workgroups, committees, and caucuses under the Council’s jurisdiction. The following is a brief report of the May 2023 meeting of the Council on Research and its plans.
Workgroups Updates
Diagnostic and Novel Treatments Workgroup
Charles Nemeroff, M.D., Ph.D., Chairperson
The Diagnostic and Novel Treatments (Biomarkers Workgroup) completed a number of manuscripts that have been approved by the Board of Trustees for submission to peer-reviewed journals for publication. A manuscript on the treatment of PTSD, led by Dr. Paul Holtzheimer, has been accepted with revisions for publication in The Lancet Psychiatry. Additionally, two manuscripts on the health and mental health consequences of the Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization decision, first authored by Dr. Nina Kraguljac, as well as review articles on pharmacogenomics in depression and psilocybin in the treatment of psychiatric disorders are being prepared for submission to peer-reviewed psychiatry journals. The workgroup’s review article on MDMA-assisted therapies was recently approved by the Council on Research to move through the process for approval for publication. In addition, the workgroup is developing papers on additional topics including the epigenetics of trauma. During the 2023 APA Annual Meeting, the workgroup held a symposium entitled, “Biomarkers in Psychiatry: Are We Ready for Prime Time?” with Drs. Nina Kraguljac, Anand Kumar, and Adrienne Grzenda as presenters, and Dr. Charles B. Nemeroff as a discussant.
Health Services and Health Disparities Workgroup
Jonathan Alpert, M.D., Ph.D., Chairperson
Members of the workgroup continue to finalize a data-driven manuscript on climate change and mental health. The work group plans to develop papers on topics such as research on suicidality and suicide safety planning particularly among traditionally unrepresented groups, integrated care for individuals with serious mental illness, and gun violence.
The workgroup held two symposia at the 2023 APA Annual Meeting. The sessions covered the concepts of structural racism in psychiatric research careers and disparities is use of restraints in psychiatric care.
The Council on Research also conducted a Presidential Session at the Annual Meeting on enhancing diversity of investigators and stakeholders in psychiatric research based in part on a manuscript from the Council on this topic published earlier in the year by AJP.
Neuromodulation Workgroup
Linda Carpenter, M.D., Chairperson
Members of this new workgroup plan to develop papers and sessions on topics related to advances in TMS, ECT, DBS and other forms of neurostimulation, and to interface with the Caucus on Neuromodulation. During the Council’s meeting during the APA Annual meeting, the workgroup worked on developing a position statement on TMS.
Workgroup on Research Training
The Council’s Workgroup on Research Training, chaired by Charles Nemeroff, M.D., Ph.D., and Steven Siegel, M.D., Ph.D., met to discuss the 2023 Research Colloquium for Junior Psychiatrist Investigators (Colloquium). The Colloquium was held on May 20–21 before the APA Annual Meeting. This year, 45 applicants were selected to attend the Colloquium including five international awardees from Brazil (2), Colombia (1), and France (2). On day one of the Colloquium, mentees participated in didactic presentations from senior researchers on topics such as work life balance, mentorship, and grantsmanship, and participated in a workshop on study design. On day two of the Colloquium, mentees broke into small groups and discussed topics such as managing a research team, working with special populations, and other hot topics in psychiatric research. Presentations from representatives of the Brain and Behavior Research Foundation, National Institute on Drug Abuse (NIDA), the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention (AFSP), and the Medical Technology Enterprise Consortium (MTEC) offered information on research funding for early research career (ERC) psychiatrists. Finally, participants divided into breakout groups of 3–4 mentees in six research areas of interest (i.e., neuroscience, treatment, clinical psychobiology, substance abuse research, health services/health disparities research, and military mental health) where they presented their research and received feedback from their assigned team Senior Research and Statistics/Methodology mentors.
The workgroup is planning the Colloquium 6-Month Booster Session which will be held on Saturday, December 2, 2023, before the American College of Neuropsychopharmacology (ACNP) Annual Meeting in Tampa, Florida. The workgroup is also planning the Colloquium 12-Month Booster Session which will be held during the 2024 Society of Biological Psychiatry (SOBP) Annual Meeting in Austin, Texas. The Colloquium continues to be jointly funded by the APA Foundation, a NIDA R-13 grant, and through our partnership with ACNP and SOBP. Additionally, the Medical Technology and Educational Consortium (MTEC) has provided 3-year partial funding to cover research on military mental health including posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), traumatic brain injury (TBI), and suicide.
We continue our work to expand the Research Colloquium to include more international ERC psychiatrists. International mentees are selected and sponsored by their institution, national psychiatric association, or branch of SOBP, or are self-funded.
Research Awards and Fellowships
The Award for Research in Psychiatry, the highest award for research given by the APA, was presented to Dr. Mark George. Several other prominent researchers were recognized this year for their outstanding contributions to psychiatry and psychiatric research: Dr. Jordan Smoller received the Mrazek Award in Psychiatric Pharmacogenomics; Dr. Tami Benton received the Blanche Ittleson Award for Research in Child/Adolescent Psychiatry; Dr. Nina Kraguljac received the Alexander Gralnick Award for Research in Schizophrenia; Dr. Benson Ku received the Health Services Research- Early Career Award, and Dr. John Krystal received the Nasrallah Family Award for Advances in Psychiatric Neuroscience. Dr. Steven Siegel and his mentee, Dr. Adam Frank, received the Kempf Fund Award for Research Development in Psychobiological Psychiatry.
The 2023 Psychiatric Research Fellowship was awarded to Dr. Brittany Gouse. Dr. Gouse’s research will investigate both the predictors of suicide and evidenced-based practices to reduce the risk of suicide in early psychosis. Dr. Gouse will leverage national CMS data to investigate the individual and neighborhood-level sociodemographic predictors of suicide attempts and suicide in the first 2 years of psychotic illness. Dr. Gouse’s fellowship began in July 2023 and will end in June 2025.
Component Updates
Committee on Psychiatric Dimensions of Disaster
Joshua Morganstein, M.D., Chairperson
The Committee on Psychiatric Dimensions of Disaster coordinated with the APA Communications Department to reach out to the district branches and state associations affected by natural disasters and other traumatic events. Additionally, the Committee continues to recruit APA members to serve as Disaster Representatives for their district branches. Committee members have led special webinars on disaster psychiatry topics and participated in interviews through major media outlets. Committee members led a two-part course on disaster response during the APA Annual Meeting. The Committee has been engaged in supporting APA’s response to multiple events including school shootings and the War in Ukraine. The Committee holds monthly mentorship meetings with the three APA/APAF fellows assigned to the Committee. The Committee is authoring an ongoing article series in Psychiatric News focused on topics of interest in disaster mental health and how others can become involved.
Committee on Climate Change and Mental Health
Joshua Wortzel, M.D., M.Phil., M.S.(Ed), Chairperson
The committee has been engaged in a number of activities to push forward education and advocacy regarding the impacts of climate change on mental health. Regarding the education of APA members, the committee held two webinars, one on the impact of heat on mental health and another on the traumatic impact of natural disasters and disaster responsiveness. The committee generated Earth Day videos and built out the APA’s website including movies and infographics. The climate committee also presented multiple symposia at the 2023 APA Annual Meeting. To educate psychiatry trainees, the committee is working with the Group for the Advancement of Psychiatry to develop a standardized curriculum on climate mental health and has submitted recommendations to the ABPN with sample questions covering this content. To educate the larger scientific community, the committee members have written peer-reviewed articles on topics pertaining to climate and mental health.
Regarding advocacy, the committee updated the APA’s position statement on climate mental health, which was passed in March 2023. With the help of the Council on Research, the committee is working on a position statement about the impact of pollution on mental health and another on the psychological impacts of climate change-related displacement, the latter in collaboration with the Council on Children, Adolescents, and Their Families. Committee members met with SAMSHA and provided a document outlining recommendations for funding for climate mental health-related topics. The committee has worked with the APA’s media and government relations groups on a number of press releases on the impacts of climate change on mental health, including contributing to a briefing to the U.S. Congress in favor of the Community Mental Wellness and Resilience Act of 2023.
Other Updates
APA Registry Discussion
As PsychPRO continues to develop and scale, the Council remains a source of guidance and support as needed. A recent leadership workgroup developing recommendations for the ‘Future of Psychiatry’ identified the critical role of a registry to ensure the continued leadership of the profession in optimizing patient care and outcomes through leveraging rapidly evolving technology and harnessing data from real world settings. Recent registry activities include refocusing, rebranding, and revising PsychPRO imagery for the 2023 Annual Meeting.
Registry participation remains stable, currently sitting at about 70 practices (including three large health care systems, Sheppard Pratt, Cambridge Health Alliance, and Hackensack Meridian) with approximately 750+ clinicians (i.e., psychiatrists, psychologists, social workers, therapists, NPs, and PAs). PsychPRO data file specifications and safe and secure data transfer processes have demonstrated that effective and efficient quality data collection will vary across EHR systems and as a result, the registry is in the process of widening the scope for vendor applications to meet the needs and required support at each practice, from small to large institutions and health care systems.
PsychPRO continues to be envisioned as providing quality data and information for APA to have a greater voice advocating for the profession and advancing the psychiatric care landscape. Informatics expertise and a next-generation registry platform as planned will empower the APA to advance health care through data science. As we continue to grow, PsychPRO will provide a high-quality data enclave for the purposes of quality measurement-based care as well as clinical research and development of learning health care systems and networks. For more information about the Registry, please go to
www.psychiatry.org/psychiatrists/registryDSM Steering Committee
Paul S. Appelbaum, M.D., Chairperson; Kenneth Kendler, M.D., and Ellen Leibenluft, M.D., Vice-Chairs
The DSM Steering Committee, as well as its Subcommittee on Minor Changes and five Review Committees, have been evaluating various proposals for updates to DSM-5-TR since the last report in October 2022. Several proposals for the addition, deletion, or modification of diagnostic criteria were received through the online portal (
https://www.psychiatry.org/psychiatrists/practice/dsm/submit-proposals) and reviewed by the DSM Steering Committee. Suggestions to update the differential diagnoses for delusional disorder, schizophrenia, and conduct disorders to clarify the text and enhance its clarity were approved. In addition, the Steering Committee continues to work with a workgroup of experts to evaluate the Alternative Model of Personality Disorders as compared to the categorical model in Section 2 of the DSM. Another workgroup is evaluating the utility and value of requesting specific ICD-10-CM diagnostic codes for specifiers of the DSM disorders.
The Steering Committee is also reviewing a proposal to clarify the possible versus probable distinctions in the neurocognitive disorders, adopted in 2022 by the National Center for Health Statistics (NCHS), as it relates to the DSM criteria. Other proposals under review include the addition of DSM diagnoses for severe acute postpartum mental disorder and suicide crisis syndrome. Five other proposals that were deemed to be insufficiently supported by the scientific literature were either rejected or the proposers were requested to provide additional information.