Insel: 'Different Kind of Science' Poised to Transform Psychiatry
Psychiatry is still awaiting the “disruptive innovations” in scientific research that have helped to reconceptualize disease in other areas of medicine, said Thomas Insel, M.D., director of the National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH), at APA's 2008 annual meeting in Washington, D.C., in May.
The study of genomic variation and its role in leading to changes in complex brain circuitry, recognition of the longitudinal and developmental nature of disorders, and the discovery of biomarkers linked to a more precise understanding of the pathophysiology of disease are the tools of a 21st-century science promising to transform the treatment of mental illness.
Insel said those same tools have been applied in other areas of medicine to reconceptualize the nature of disease and to reduce mortality dramatically for people with such disorders as cardiovascular disease and cancer.
In contrast, the diagnosis and treatment of mental illness, he said, have been stuck in a 20th-century model.
NIMH Director Thomas Insel, M.D.: “Genes code for proteins that play out in particular brain areas at particular times to change the way brain circuitry develops. It's all about variation and how it plays out at each of these levels.”
Credit: Mark Moran
“By comparison, when one looks at mental illness, I think it's fair to say that unlike the rest of medicine we are locked into diagnosis by observation, we make our diagnoses late in the [trajectory of disease], and our ability to predict disease is not very good,” Insel said. “We don't know much about the causes of the disorders we treat, and treatment is largely by trial and error.”
Nonetheless, progress is being made. He outlined a number of areas in which psychiatric research is moving slowly in the direction of new strategies of scientific discovery—what Insel called “disruptive innovations”—that will provide a radically altered understanding of the nature of mental illness.
These include recent research showing that the conditions psychiatrists treat are disorders of complex brain circuitry; that they typically begin years before they come to the attention of a clinician; and that they are the result of multiple genetic variations, each of which may confer a degree of risk over time until the balance is tipped toward disease.
He cited, for instance, research from the intramural program at NIMH using structural imaging to compare brain changes in healthy children with those of children with a variety of neuropsychiatric illnesses. In one study, the brains of children between 7 and 12 years of age with and without ADHD were studied at two-year intervals over several years. The children with ADHD were found to have marked thinning of cortical areas.
The study, “Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder Is Characterized By a Delay in Cortical Maturation,” was published in the December 7, 2007, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. An abstract of the article is posted at<www.pnas.org/cgi/content/short/104/49/19649>.
“It turns out that children with ADHD are about three years behind [their healthy counterparts] in cortical maturation,” Insel said.“ This tells us that this disorder that we have defined on the basis of cognitive and behavioral manifestations is a brain disease, a disease of cortical maturation.
“Looking at it in this way raises all sorts of new questions,” he continued. “What causes the delay in maturation? Do medications that reduce the behavioral and cognitive aspects have any impact on this maturation? So now we have an opportunity to think about this disorder in a way that is very different from where we have been.”
But Insel cautioned that to say that psychiatric illnesses are brain disorders is not to equate them with neurological disorders, which typically stem from lesions in a particular part of the brain. Rather, it appears that complex social behavior—including the abnormal behavior, feelings, and cognition that are typically called mental illness—is related to abnormal development of interrelated networks, or circuits, in the brain.
“Neurology deals primarily with focal lesions, places where you can find dead cells,” he said. “Psychiatry is going to deal with circuit problems. You might use as an analogy the difference between studying myocardial infarction versus studying left bundle branch block. Both of them can kill you, but only one of them is going to give you gross pathology in the way that we think about when we think about neurological illness.”
He highlighted work by Helen Mayberg, M.D., of Emory University, showing that the so-called Brodmann's area 25 of the brain, located under the corpus collosum, may be central in depression. Area 25 appears to be decreased in volume and increased in metabolic activity among people who are depressed; moreover, there appears to be a reduction in metabolic activity among people who receive antidepressant medication or cognitive-behavioral therapy (Psychiatric News, June 20).
But he stressed that decreased volume in area 25 should not be thought of as a focal lesion that is the cause of all depression; rather, it appears to be a conduit for serotonin and other neurochemicals known to be associated with depression and negative rumination.
“It would be a mistake to think of this as the 'home of depression,'” Insel said. “It is important to remember that this is a circuit, a gateway for many of the fibers [associated with depression].”
Moreover, many psychiatric disorders are developmental, beginning many years before they typically come to clinical attention, said Insel.“ They start early in life, but we tend to make the diagnosis many years after the onset,” Insel said. “It is almost a truism that psychiatric diagnosis is made so late that it is unlikely we will be able to get the full recovery that we would like.”
Insel cited research showing that adolescents with the APOE4 gene for Alzheimer's have decreased volume in critical areas of the cortex and show subtle deficits in cognition, decades before they would ever show symptoms of Alzheimer's.
That kind of predictive capability is now being developed, slowly, for schizophrenia. “We still think of schizophrenia as psychosis,” he said. “But that is the worst outcome of a very long developmental process that we are unable to detect until one of these very severe events, when it is most difficult to get the kind of full recovery and remission you want.”
He said research on the schizophrenia prodrome—the preclinical period that precedes an acute psychotic break—has shown that adolescents with a family history of schizophrenia along with functional deficits and other anomalous symptoms can be predicted with 80 percent accuracy to convert to psychosis.
Finally, Insel said, the deepening understanding of genomic variation and how it affects normal or abnormal development of brain circuits in different ways at different periods over time will help push psychiatric diagnosis and treatment into 21st-century medicine.
“One thing we won't get is a code for diagnosis,” Insel said.“ These are variations that contribute small amounts of risk; each variation may contribute 2 or 3 percent risk.”
At some point the balance of risk and protective factors tips toward disease. But he cautioned that it would be a mistake to think that research will identify specific genes that cause schizophrenia.
“Genes code for proteins that play out in particular brain areas at particular times to change the way brain circuitry develops. It's all about variation and how it plays out at each of these levels.”
Ultimately, a 21st-century neuropsychiatry in which the true pathophysiology of mental illness is understood—from genes to neurons to brain circuits and systems to behavior—will yield a new individualized psychiatry.
“We need a different kind of science to tailor treatments and allow clinicians to choose from many different options... that are personalized and preemptive,” Insel said. “That is where we are going to get the biggest impact.” ▪
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
History
Published online: 4 July 2008
Published in print: July 4, 2008
Notes
Understanding genomic variation and how it affects normal or abnormal development of brain circuits in different ways at different points in time will help push psychiatric diagnosis and treatment into the 21st century.
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Export Citations
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.
For more information or tips please see 'Downloading to a citation manager' in the Help menu.
View Options
View options
Login options
Already a subscriber? Access your subscription through your login credentials or your institution for full access to this article.
Personal login Institutional Login Open Athens loginNot a subscriber?
PsychiatryOnline subscription options offer access to the DSM-5-TR® library, books, journals, CME, and patient resources. This all-in-one virtual library provides psychiatrists and mental health professionals with key resources for diagnosis, treatment, research, and professional development.
Need more help? PsychiatryOnline Customer Service may be reached by emailing [email protected] or by calling 800-368-5777 (in the U.S.) or 703-907-7322 (outside the U.S.).