Management of HIV-Positive Psychiatric Patients Who Fail to Reduce High-Risk Behaviors

The authors describe clinical and legal dilemmas faced by staff involved in providing inpatient psychiatric treatment to two HIV carriers who continued to practice high-risk behaviors after learning of their HIV infection. Staff were unsure of their obligation to report the patients under a state law giving the commissioner of health broad discretion to limit the freedoms of HIV-infected individuals who continue to practice high-risk behaviors. Treatment of the patients also raised concerns about the appropriateness of treating noncompliant HIV-infected patients in traditional psychiatric settings and the lack of suitable aftercare facilities. The authors advocate developing a specialized treatment approach for noncompliant HIV-infected patients and provide a series of recommendations that might serve as the foundation for such an effort.