Mercury Exposure: Effects Across the Lifespan

Mercury vapor is highly diffusible and lipid soluble, thus it is easily absorbed. 3, 7 Initially it distributes principally to red blood cells and then throughout the body. It crosses both the blood-brain and blood-placental barriers. Studies in nonhuman primates of mercury deposition in the cortex following exposure to mercury vapor found a clear laminar pattern in adults, with higher concentrations in pyramidal cells in the deeper layers. 9 Exposure in utero resulted in a lower level of deposition into the brain that was similar in all layers. The dissolved mercury vapor can oxidize to form inorganic mercuric mercury, a process that is inhibited by ethanol. Elimination is slow, with an average half-life of about 8 weeks for the body and possibly years for the brain. 3, 10 Fecal elimination predominates during the first week, with renal elimination predominating thereafter. Thus, urinary level of mercury (usually expressed as μg Hg/g creatinine or μg Hg/liter urine) is commonly used as an indicator for chronic exposure to mercury vapor and/or inorganic mercury compounds. 11 Unlike methylmercury, these are not readily accumulated into hair. 3, 11

Symptoms of acute intoxication include shortness of breath, chest pain, dyspnea, paroxysmal cough, chills, nausea and vomiting, diffuse joint swelling, and rash. 3, 12 Chronic exposure commonly results in oral cavity lesions, tremor, decreased coordination, decreased sensation, and psychiatric symptoms including anxiety, excessive timidity, and pathological fear of ridicule ( Figure 1 ). Acrodynia (pink disease), a rare reaction to elemental or inorganic mercury exposure in children, is characterized by sweating, redness and swelling in the hands and feet, progressive weight loss, insomnia, weakness, apathy, hypotonia, hypertension, and tachycardia. 3, 5, 13, 14 The similarity in presentation to pheochromocytoma has been noted. 14, 15 MRI findings have included hyperintense lesions in multiple regions such as the paracentral area, frontal white matter, and basal ganglia ( Figure 1 ). 12, 13 A single slice single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) study in a patient with chronic inorganic mercury poisoning showed increased regional cerebral blood flow (rCBF) in the posterior cingulate. 12

Clear toxicity has been reported for exposures resulting in urinary levels of 50 to 100 μg Hg/liter. The effects of lower levels are still a subject for debate. A recent review of studies of dental professionals, for example, concluded that the evidence for adverse effects in adults associated with urinary levels ≤22 μg Hg/liter was weak. 3 They noted, however, that these studies did not address the possibility of much higher exposures in the past resulting in irreversible effects. The potential toxicity associated with amalgam dental fillings is a particular area of controversy. An autopsy study in adults that measured both organic and inorganic mercury in blood and body tissues estimated an increase of about 1.5 μg Hg/kg of occipital cortex for every 10 amalgam dental fillings. 16 The authors noted that individual differences were considerable, and correlation between number of amalgam fillings and inorganic mercury in the brain accounted for only 30% of the variance. Two recent randomized studies in children compared neurobehavioral measures between groups receiving amalgam and resin composite fillings. 17, 18 Both studies found significantly increased urinary mercury in the amalgam group at follow-up. In one, measures at the 5-year follow-up examination indicated no significant differences between groups in full-scale IQ (study powered to detect a 3-point reduction) or in tests of memory and visuomotor function. 17 In the other, measures at the 7-year follow-up examination indicated no significant differences in memory, attention, visuomotor function, or nerve conduction velocities. 18 As noted by authors of both studies and in the accompanying editorial, neither study was designed to address effects in potentially more vulnerable populations (e.g., genetic predisposition to mercury toxicity, patients younger than 6 years old). 19

Although there are many other organic mercury compounds, most human exposure is to methylmercury, which crosses both the blood-brain and blood-placental barriers and principally damages the CNS. 3, 20 Ingested methylmercury is distributed first to the blood and then throughout the body, with ∼5% remaining in the blood. The mercury content of red blood cells provides a reliable measure of methylmercury exposure in the absence of significant exposure to inorganic mercury compounds. 11 The ratio of brain to blood concentration is in the range of 5 to 10:1. 21 Elimination is primarily through feces, with a half-life of 6 to 10 weeks. 3, 21 Methylmercury is also converted to inorganic mercury by intestinal flora. Scalp hair accumulates methylmercury, and analysis of one cm segments is used as a surrogate measure to estimate monthly exposure history for the brain. 3, 11, 21 This method is less than ideal, however, as there is no way to differentiate mercury that is within the hair from mercury that is on the surface. 22 Cleaning procedures will not reliably remove surface mercury. 22, 23 External contamination may occur from a variety of sources, including nearby gold mining and use of mercury-containing personal care products. Analysis of toenail clippings has also been used to estimate exposure to methylmercury. 16

The major route of exposure to methylmercury is through consumption of fish and marine mammals. Inorganic mercury, present in the environment as a result of emissions from both natural (e.g., volcanoes) and human (e.g., coal-burning power stations) sources, is converted to methylmercury within microorganisms in aquatic sediments, allowing it to enter the food chain. Biomagnification occurs at each ascending level of the food chain. Thus, the highest concentrations are found in muscles of longer-living aquatic predators (e.g., pike, shark), principally as a methylmercury cysteine complex. 24 Industrial pollution is another source. It can result in localized areas in which the level of methylmercury in fish is very high, as happened in Minamata Bay in Japan. The other major occurrence of widespread mercury poisoning resulted from the use of seed grain that had been treated with methylmercury fungicide for bread making in rural areas of Iraq. 3 Studies over the past several decades of these two populations have helped to delineate the effects of both adult and prenatal methylmercury exposure. 3, 25 Methylmercury’s high affinity for thiol groups provides multiple potential targets, and many possible mechanisms for neurotoxicity of methylmercury have been proposed. 26, 27 Animal studies indicate that methylmercury can induce cell death by both apoptosis and necrosis. It can have multiple deleterious actions at the cellular level, including disruption of microtubules (a key cytoskeletal component), increased generation of reactive oxygen species, and disruption of calcium homeostasis.

Symptoms of acute exposure to methylmercury in adults (Minamata disease) may include impairments in all primary sensory modalities (blurred vision, with bilateral and symmetric constriction of the visual fields; bilateral deficits in hearing, with speech discrimination more impaired than pure tone; deficits in smell and taste; distal paresthesias with preserved or hyperactive tendon reflexes) as well as dysarthria and cerebellar ataxia. Psychiatric symptoms are common and include loss of volition and apathy, excessive interpersonal sensitivity, perseveration, and loss of inhibition. 3, 25, 27 Symptoms may not be immediate, but rather may first occur weeks to months after the exposure. 3, 27 In one well-documented case, a scientist first displayed clear signs of poisoning 4 months after a single exposure to dimethylmercury. 28 Mercury in this form is easily absorbed through the skin and by inhalation and is highly toxic. Postmortem studies indicate that the most vulnerable sites in the cerebrum are the primary sensory and motor cortices (calcarine region, precentral gyrus, postcentral gyrus, temporal transverse gyrus) ( Figure 2 ). 25, 27 – 29 Cerebellar granule cells (but not Purkinje cells) are also very vulnerable. Evidence of perivascular edema and demyelination are common. Secondary degeneration of tracts is seen in patients with long survival times. Chronic exposure to methylmercury in adults is most commonly manifested in distal paresthesias. 25 Touch threshold is increased in all areas of the body. Cerebellar ataxia is not usually seen, but sensory ataxia and pseudoathetoid movements may be present. The injury is to the somatosensory cortex, as indicated by preservation of tendon reflexes, normal conduction velocity in the sural nerve, and abnormality of the short-latency somatosensory evoked potential. A SPECT study compared rCBF in elderly patients with mild chronic methylmercury poisoning to age-matched healthy individuals. 30 The groups had similar incidence of white matter abnormalities on MRI. There were no significant differences in cortical rCBF between the groups. Cerebellar atrophy was present in 27% of the patients with methylmercury exposure and none of the participants in the matched comparison group. Regional CBF was significantly decreased in cerebellum even in patients without visible atrophy.

Vulnerability to methylmercury poisoning is age-related, with susceptibility decreasing with increasing age. 2 Exposure to organic mercury compounds during gestation results in severe injury to the infant brain at dose levels below those that are toxic to the mother. 2, 3, 20, 25, 27 High exposure can result in very severe developmental disorders (e.g., mental retardation, cerebral palsy, blindness, deafness) ( Figure 3 ). 2, 27 Symptoms of moderate exposure include psychomotor and personality disturbances, intellectual deficits, and epilepsy. Unlike the focal neuropathological changes that are found following adult exposure, prenatal and early childhood exposure results in very widespread changes including status spongiosus of the cerebral cortex ( Figure 3 ). 2, 3, 25, 27, 29

Lower levels of prenatal exposure are associated with more subtle deficits such as developmental delays. However, differences among the major epidemiological studies complicate identification of lowest-observed adverse effects level. 3, 20, 27 One very important difference that makes comparisons across studies difficult is in the type of seafood consumed. In one study, the major source of methylmercury was routine consumption of sea fish (mercury level <0.5 μg/g, 0.3 ppm). In another study, a major source was episodic consumption of pilot whale meat (mercury level up to 3 μg/g, 1.6 ppm) and blubber, resulting in much higher periodic mercury exposures as well as exposure to other toxic substances contained in the blubber. 3, 31 Competition between positive and negative factors complicates analysis. The possible long-term detrimental effects of occasional exposure to higher levels of mercury and the potentially protective effects of the various nutritional factors contained in fish (e.g., long chain polyunsaturated fats, micronutrients, selenium) may be relevant. 3, 31 – 35 Other aspects of maternal diet, such as alcohol consumption and fiber intake, may also be important as they can alter absorption and/or elimination of methylmercury. 3

The other organic mercury compound that is presently of great interest is ethylmercury thiosalicylate (thimerosal, Merthiolate), which until recently was commonly used as a preservative in medicines, including vaccines. Use in vaccines was halted in the United States based on lowered exposure limits for methylmercury issued by the Environmental Protection Agency. 36 A recent study in nonhuman primate infants compared brain and blood levels of mercury following exposure to either ethylmercury (intramuscular injection, dosing designed to mimic typical vaccination schedule) or methylmercury (oral, equivalent total dose of mercury). 37 The absorption rates and initial distribution volumes for mercury were similar. Uptake into brain and elimination from the body were quite different. Concentration of mercury in the brain following ethylmercury administration was approximately one-third the level found following methylmercury administration. More than 30% was in the less toxic inorganic form, compared to less than 10% for methylmercury. Clearance of ethylmercury was also two to three times faster than methylmercury for both blood and brain. As noted by the authors, 37 these results indicate that methylmercury is not an appropriate reference for assessing risk related to ethylmercury exposure. These results have been partially confirmed in human infants. 38 The blood half-life of ethylmercury in infants following intramuscular injection of vaccine is much shorter than the blood half-life of oral methylmercury in adults.

The proposed association between thimerosal exposure and autistic spectrum disorder has received extensive attention. 36 As recently reviewed, most epidemiological studies have not found an increased incident of autistic spectrum disorder due to vaccine exposure. 39 A case control study found no significant difference in hair or blood mercury level between children with autistic spectrum disorder and healthy children, although others have disagreed with this analysis. 40, 41 It has been suggested that some individuals with autistic spectrum disorder may have heightened vulnerability due to impaired elimination of mercury. 42 Mechanisms that have been implicated include lower glutathione levels, altered immune system function, and elevated exposure to oral antibiotics early in life. 43, 44

Both acute and chronic exposure to toxic substances may contribute to the development of neurodegenerative diseases such as Alzheimer’s disease, Parkinson’s disease, and amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. 8, 45, 46 Injury can occur by direct mechanisms and/or indirectly by altering susceptibility at later ages to disease development. For example, elevated levels of mercury have been found in both blood and brain in patients with Alzheimer’s disease, suggesting that its accumulation may be a factor in the development of this disease. 47 Proposed mechanisms for delayed effects include mercury-induced increased formation of insoluble β-amyloid, mercury-induced increased formation of reactive oxygen species during oxidative stress, excitotoxicity due to inhibition of glutamate reuptake, and increased glial reactivity promoting neuroinflammatory processes. 8, 47, 48

In summary, mercury has been known since antiquity to be both a useful and a harmful heavy metal. As one examines patients across the lifespan, significant exposures at younger ages are most devastating. However, chronic lower level exposures at any age can also lead to neuropsychiatric symptomology and reaffirms the necessity to include poison/toxin exposure questions in a clinical interview.

Drs. Taber and Hurley are affiliated with the Veterans Affairs Mid-Atlantic Mental Illness Research, Education, and Clinical Center, and the Mental Health Service Line at the W.G. Hefner Veterans Affairs Medical Center in Salisbury, N.C. Dr. Taber is affiliated with the Division of Biomedical Sciences at the Virginia College of Osteopathic Medicine in Blacksburg, Va., and the Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation at Baylor College of Medicine in Houston, Tex.; Dr. Hurley is affiliated with the Departments of Psychiatry and Radiology at Wake Forest University School of Medicine in Winston-Salem, N.C., and the Menninger Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences at Baylor College of Medicine in Houston. Address correspondence to Dr. Robin Hurley, Hefner VA Medical Center, 1601 Brenner Ave., Salisbury, NC 28144; [email protected] (e-mail).