Impact of Patients’ Psychiatric Hospitalization on Caregivers: A Systematic Review
Abstract
Objective:
Methods:
Results:
Conclusions:
Methods
Results
Study and country | Caregiver type | Caregiver race | Patient race and age group | Previously hospitalized | Patient diagnosis |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Bauer et al., 2011 (37); Germany | 18 spouses, 7 parents, 3 children, 3 siblings, 1 friend | nr | nr | nr | 32 bipolar disorder |
Clarke and Winsor, 2010 (20); Canada | 9 mothers, 1 father | nr | nr; adults | nr | nr |
Dore and Romans, 2001 (21); New Zealand | 15 parents, 13 partners, 9 other relatives, 3 friends, 1 sibling | nr | nr; adults | nr | Bipolar disorder |
Gerson et al., 2009 (22); U.S. | 9 mothers, 3 fathers, 1 brother, 1 aunt | nr | 5 white, 4 Hispanic, 3 black, 1 East Asian; youths and adults | nr | 6 schizophrenia, 6 psychotic disorder NOS, 1 schizoaffective disorder |
Hanson, 1995 (10); U.S. | 20 mothers, 9 fathers, 2 wives, 2 sisters, 1 in-law | nr | nr; adults | Average of 5.6 | nr |
Heru et al., 2004 (31); U.S. | 24 spouses, 8 parents, 4 children, 2 others, 1 sibling | nr | nr; adults | nr | 22 major depressive disorder, 17 bipolar disorder |
Heru and Ryan, 2004 (32); U.S. | 11 spouses, 4 parents, 2 children, 2 others | nr | nr; adults | nr | 10 major depressive disorder, 9 bipolar disorder |
Hinrichsen and Lieberman, 1999 (17); U.S. | 33 mothers or stepmothers, 11 fathers, 7 siblings, 6 spouses, 4 other family | nr | 27 white, 24 black, 12 Hispanic, Asian, or other; adults | First | 45 schizophrenia, 13 schizoaffective disorder and depression, 5 schizoaffective disorder and manic |
King et al., 1993 (13); U.S. | 53 both parents, 26 single biological parents, 13 biological and stepparents, 7 neither parent | nr | 91 white, 6 other, 5 black; youths | nr | 51 major depressive disorder and suicidal behaviors, 23 behavior disorder and suicidal behaviors, 18 dysthymia, 16 anxiety disorder, 14 eating disorder, 9 bipolar disorder, 2 psychotic disorder |
King et al., 1997 (12); U.S. | 74 parents | nr | 57 white, 6 black, 3 other; youths | nr | 48 major depressive disorder, 16 conduct disorder, 15 dysthymia, 12 alcohol use disorder, 10 other substance use disorder, 10 social phobia, 9 ADHD, 8 generalized anxiety disorder, 7 oppositional defiant disorder, 7 eating disorder, 6 separation anxiety disorder,6 PTSD, 4 bipolar disorder, 1 depressive disorder NOS |
Kjellin and Ostman, 2005 (25); Sweden | 45 spouses, 42 parents, 18 children, 42 siblings or other relatives, 8 close friends | nr | nr; adults | nr | 48 schizophrenia, delusional disorders, schizoaffective disorder, schizophreniform disorder, or atypical psychosis; 67 affective mood disorder, 40 other |
Knox and Singh, 2007 (38); U.S. | 51 mothers, 4 grandmothers, 3 fathers, 1 foster mother | nr | 48 white, 5 black, 4 Hispanic, 4 biracial or other; youths | nr | nr |
Lauber et al., 2003 (28); Switzerland | 64 caregivers | nr | nr | nr | Schizophrenia |
Möller-Leimkühler, 2005 (33); Germany | 65 spouses, 17 parents, 1 brother | nr | nr | nr | Schizophrenia, major depressive disorder |
Möller-Leimkühler, 2006 (34); Germany | 52 spouses, 16 parents, 1 brother | nr | nr | nr | Schizophrenia, major depressive disorder |
Möller-Leimkühler and Obermeier, 2008 (36); Germany | 51 spouses, 11 parents, | nr | nr | nr | Schizophrenia, major depressive disorder |
Möller-Leimkühler and Mädger, 2011 (35); Germany | 52 spouses, 11 parents | nr | nr | nr | Schizophrenia, major depressive disorder |
Ostman et al., 2000 (27); Sweden | 35 parents, 26 spouses, 11 children, 7 other relatives, 3 nonrelatives | nr | nr; adults | nr | 54 psychosis; 34 major depressive disorder, bipolar disorder, or anxiety disorder; 12 other |
Owens and Qualls, 1997 (18); U.S. | 22 children, 5 spouses, 4 parents, 1 sibling | nr | 23 white; adults | nr | nr |
Phelan et al., 1998 (19); U.S. | 29 spouses, 94 parents who live with patient, 45 parents who do not live with patient, 27 others | 154 white, 247 black, 14 Hispanic | nr; youths and adults | First | nr |
Puotiniemi et al., 2001 (29); Finland | 55 mothers, 23 fathers, 1 stepmother, | nr | nr; youths | 79% first hospitalization | nr |
Puotiniemi et al., 2002 (30); Finland | 55 mothers, 23 fathers, 1 stepmother | nr | nr; youths | 79% first hospitalization | Emotional and conduct disorders, major depressive disorder, ADHD, eating disorders |
Ronan et al., 2008 (14); U.S. | 60 parents | nr | nr; youths | nr | 25 major depressive disorder, 13 dysthymia, 7 ADHD, 7 adjustment disorder, 5 conduct disorders, 2 anxiety disorders, 1 schizophrenia |
Schmid et al., 2009 (11); Germany | 37 siblings | nr | nr; adults | nr | 37 schizophrenia |
Snell et al., 2010 (15); U.S. | 35 mothers, 2 fathers, 1 nonparental figure | nr | nr; youths | 32% previously hospitalized | Major depressive disorder, bipolar II disorder, adjustment disorder with depressed mood, and depressive disorder secondary to a general medical condition |
Solomon et al., 1988 (23); U.S. | 13 parents | nr | 16 white; adults | Average of 9 | Schizophrenia |
Stueve et al., 1997 (24); U.S. | 180 caregivers | 93 white, 43 black, 43 Hispanic | nr; adults | nr | Schizophrenia, major depressive disorder |
Thompson and Doll, 1982 (26); U.S. | 53 parents, 44 spouses, 30 siblings, children, or relatives | 73 white | nr; adults | nr | nr |
Wagner et al., 2000 (16); U.S. | 19 biological mothers, 6 biological fathers, 5 stepfathers, 1 stepmother, 1 adoptive mother, 1 adoptive father, 1 grandmother | 20 white, 3 black, 1 Hispanic | 18 white, 3 black, 2 Hispanic; youths | nr | Serious suicide attempt |
Study and country | Data sourceb | Time of assessment | Primary outcome |
---|---|---|---|
Bauer et al., 2011 (37); Germany | Problem-focused semistructured interviews | nr | Degree of patients’ illness, degree of support |
Clarke and Winsor, 2010 (20); Canada | Qualitative interviews | nr | Personal well-being, stigma |
Dore and Romans, 2001 (21); New Zealand | Semistructured interviews using the General Health Questionnaire | 2 years posthospitalization | Personal well-being, stigma, daily life, economic strain, relationship changes, positive impact |
Gerson et al., 2009 (22); U.S. | Qualitative interviews | During hospitalization | Personal well-being, stigma |
Hanson, 1995 (10); U.S. | Qualitative interviews | nr | Personal well-being |
Heru et al., 2004 (31); U.S. | Caregiver Strain Scale, visual analog scales | nr | Personal well-being, general medical health, positive impact |
Heru and Ryan, 2004 (32); U.S. | Family Assessment Device, MOS-36, Caregiver Strain Scale, Instrumental Activities of Daily Living | 1 year posthospitalization | Positive impact |
Hinrichsen and Lieberman, 1999 (17); U.S. | Health and Daily Living Form, Dementia Management Strategies Scale, Patient Rejection Scale, Burden Interview, SCL-90 | Shortly after admission | Personal well-being, coping, caregiver attributes |
King et al., 1993 (13); U.S. | SCL-90-Revised, SAS-SR, McMaster Family Assessment Device | During hospitalization | Personal well-being |
King et al., 1997 (12); U.S. | SCL-90-Revised, SAS-SR | During hospitalization and 6 to 8 months posthospitalization | Personal well-being, relationship |
Kjellin and Ostman, 2005 (25); Sweden | Semistructured questionnaire | 1 month after admission | Personal well-being, daily life |
Knox and Singh, 2007 (38); U.S. | Parenting Stress Index | During hospitalization | Personal well-being |
Lauber et al., 2003 (28); Switzerland | Semistructured interviews | 4 years and 3 months after admission | Personal well-being, daily life, relationship changes |
Möller-Leimkühler, 2005 (33); Germany | 5-minute speech sample, Family Questionnaire, semistructured biographical interviews, family burden questionnaire, subjective beliefs of competence and control (German questionnaire), NEO Five-Factor Inventory, perceived social support (German questionnaire), Lancashire Quality of Life Profile | Baseline, with unspecified details | Personal well-being, coping |
Möller-Leimkühler, 2006 (34); Germany | Qualitative interview, generalized stress response, Ways of Coping Checklist (German version), subjective beliefs of competence and control, NEO Five-Factor Inventory, perceived social support, subjective well-being, SCL-90-Revised, Lancashire Quality of Life Profile | 1 year posthospitalization | Personal well-being, stress, diagnoses |
Möller-Leimkühler and Obermeier, 2008 (36); Germany | Qualitative interview, generalized stress response, Ways of Coping Checklist (German version), subjective beliefs of competence and control, NEO Five-Factor Inventory, perceived social support, subjective well-being, SCL-90-R, Lancashire Quality of Life Profile | 2 years posthospitalization | Personal well-being, burden |
Möller-Leimkühler and Mädger, 2011 (35); Germany | NEO Five-Factor Inventory, family burden questionnaire, SCL-90 | 2 years posthospitalization | Personal well-being, gender differences |
Ostman et al., 2000 (27); Sweden | Semistructured questionnaire | During hospitalization | Personal well-being, care, support |
Owens and Qualls, 1997 (18); U.S. | Life Experiences Survey, Burden Interview, Brief Symptom Inventory, responsible family member evaluation form | During hospitalization | Personal well-being |
Phelan et al., 1998 (19); U.S. | Open-ended questions from SAS | Baseline, with unspecified details and 6 months postbaseline assessment | Stigma |
Puotiniemi et al., 2001 (29); Finland | Questionnaires with 93 items (5-point Likert scales) on 5 topics: coping, coping demands, coping strategies, coping resources, and social support | During hospitalization, with measures provided, unspecified when returned | Personal well-being, economic strain, Relationship changes |
Puotiniemi et al., 2002 (30); Finland | Questionnaires, open-ended questions about social support | During hospitalization, with measures provided, unspecified when returned | Economic strain, relationship changes |
Ronan et al., 2008 (14); U.S. | SCL-90-R, Life Experiences Survey, problem solving inventory, 3 subscales from the McMaster Family Assessment Device | 3 days after admission | Personal well-being |
Schmid et al., 2009 (11); Germany | Narrative interviews | nr | Personal well-being, relationship changes, positive impact |
Snell et al., 2010 (15); U.S. | Semistructured interviews, global assessment of each caregiver's emotional state, caregiver interviews | During hospitalization and 2 to 6 weeks after first assessment | Personal well-being |
Solomon et al., 1988 (23); U.S. | Qualitative interviews, survey item | During hospitalization | Stigma, economic strain, relationship changes |
Stueve et al., 1997 (24); U.S. | Perceived burden scale, Brief psychiatric symptom scale, caregiver help scale, network help scale, network quality scale | Baseline, with unspecified details, and 6 to 12 months postbaseline | Personal well-being, stigma |
Thompson and Doll, 1982 (26); U.S. | Index of family member embarrassment, incomplete-sentence blank test | Recruitment began six months postdischarge, other details unspecified | Personal well-being, economic strain, burden |
Wagner et al., 2000 (16); U.S. | Reaction to suicide attempt scale (modification of statement rating scale), family history interview | During hospitalization | Personal well-being |
Effects of Psychiatric Hospitalization on Caregivers
Psychological well-being.
Stigma.
Daily life.
Economic strain.
General medical health.
Relationships.
Positive impact.
Changes Over Time
Factors Influencing the Impact on Caregivers
Discussion
Practice Implications
Research Implications
Conclusions
References
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
History
Authors
Funding Information
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Export Citations
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.
For more information or tips please see 'Downloading to a citation manager' in the Help menu.
View Options
View options
PDF/EPUB
View PDF/EPUBGet Access
Login options
Already a subscriber? Access your subscription through your login credentials or your institution for full access to this article.
Personal login Institutional Login Open Athens loginNot a subscriber?
PsychiatryOnline subscription options offer access to the DSM-5-TR® library, books, journals, CME, and patient resources. This all-in-one virtual library provides psychiatrists and mental health professionals with key resources for diagnosis, treatment, research, and professional development.
Need more help? PsychiatryOnline Customer Service may be reached by emailing [email protected] or by calling 800-368-5777 (in the U.S.) or 703-907-7322 (outside the U.S.).