Serving Those Who Served: Retention of Newly Returning Veterans From Iraq and Afghanistan in Mental Health Treatment
Abstract
Objective:
There are growing concerns about the mental health status of returning veterans from the recent conflicts in Iraq (Operation Iraq Freedom [OIF]) and Afghanistan (Operation Enduring Freedom [OEF]) and about retention in mental health treatment of veterans with posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD). This study obtained data from veterans who had a new diagnosis of PTSD from fiscal year (FY) 2004 to FY 2007 and determined whether retention in PTSD treatment and the number of mental health visits were comparable among OIF-OEF veterans and veterans from other service eras.
Methods:
Data from the Department of Veterans Affairs and the Department of Defense were combined to identify veterans who were newly diagnosed as having PTSD (N=204,184) and their service era. Survival analysis assessed dropout from mental health treatment within one year from initial diagnosis, and Poisson regression assessed the association between war era and number of mental health visits.
Results:
Although a smaller proportion of OIF-OEF veterans than Vietnam-era veterans remained in treatment for more than one year (37.6% versus 46.0%), when the analyses adjusted for demographic characteristics and comorbid diagnoses, OIF-OEF veterans were less likely than Vietnam-era veterans to discontinue psychiatric treatment for PTSD within one year. OIF-OEF veterans attended fewer mental health visits than Vietnam-era veterans did (8.15 versus 13.37). However, multivariate analysis indicated that, after the analyses adjusted for confounding factors, OIF-OEF veterans had significantly more visits than Vietnam-era veterans associated with PTSD treatment.
Conclusions:
Retention and numbers of visits were found to be lower among OIF-OEF veterans primarily as a function of age and comorbid conditions and not as a function of the particular war era. Interventions should be designed to target specific barriers to care that may interfere with continued engagement in mental health services. (Psychiatric Services 62:22–27, 2011)
There is considerable public and professional concern about access to mental health services for recently returned veterans of the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. A survey of three groups of veterans (N=3,671) who returned from Afghanistan and Iraq found that 11%–17% met screening criteria for a mental disorder but 60%–77% of those who met screening criteria expressed no interest in treatment (1,2). Moreover, although 78%–86% of those who screened positive for depression, posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), or generalized anxiety disorder acknowledged these emotional difficulties, only 38%–45% indicated an interest in receiving help and only 13%–21% had actually received help from a mental health professional in the year before assessment. High rates of mental disorders were also recorded among Vietnam-era veterans and military personnel in the 1990s, and the burden associated with mental illnesses in these populations was found to be significant (3–5).
Unmet needs for mental health services are not unique to veterans. Using data from the National Comorbidity Survey, Kessler and colleagues (6,7) estimated that ten million persons in the United States meet criteria for a serious mental illness in any given year but only 50%–60% receive treatment. Fifty-five percent of those who did not receive services cited a lack of perceived need, and the rest wanted to solve the problem on their own (72%), thought the problem would get better by itself (61%), faced financial barriers (46%), were unsure about where to go for help (41%), or thought that help would not do any good (38%). In this national sample, younger people (aged 18–34) were the least likely to seek care, a finding consistent with data from the military showing limited help-seeking behavior among the younger veterans (8).
In addition to this evidence of widespread untreated mental illness, the attrition of patients who have entered psychiatric treatment has also long been a concern. Studies from the 1950s and 1960s reported that about 50% of patients dropped out of psychiatric treatment by the third session, with approximately 35% of clients ending therapy after a single session (9–11). More recent studies show that from 20% to 57% of patients drop out after the first session of mental health treatment (12–16). It has also been reported that more than 65% of clients end psychotherapy before the tenth session, and most have been found to attend fewer than six sessions (13,17).
Premature dropout is a concern for several reasons. Research has shown that successful symptom reduction in short-term, evidence-based psychotherapy usually requires a minimum of nine to 15 sessions for even half of the clients to be considered recovered (18,19). Thus the majority of clients who enter treatment do not seem to receive the minimum number of sessions needed to achieve clinical benefits. Premature dropout may also waste limited mental health resources.
This study used national administrative data from the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) to examine the one-year duration of participation in mental health treatment among veterans with a new diagnosis of PTSD and who served in Iraq as part of Operation Iraq Freedom (OIF) or who served in Afghanistan as part of Operation Enduring Freedom (OEF). These veterans were compared with veterans newly diagnosed as having PTSD from other service eras: Korean, Vietnam, post-Vietnam (1975–1992), or Persian Gulf (1992 to the present), excluding veterans who served in Iraq or Afghanistan as part of OIF or OEF.
Methods
Source of data and sample
The sample was based on national VA administrative data. Veterans were included if they were treated in the Veterans Health Administration (VHA) from fiscal year (FY) 2004 to FY 2007 and received a primary or secondary diagnosis of PTSD on at least one outpatient encounter or inpatient discharge and who had not had any service encounters associated with a PTSD diagnosis for the previous three years (since FY 2001) (N=204,184). One-year treatment discontinuation was defined if the last PTSD-related encounter occurred less than 360 days after the initiation of the service episode for treatment of PTSD. Data on service use, sociodemographic and diagnostic characteristics, and service era were derived from national administrative databases, including the outpatient encounter file, which documents all outpatient service use, and the patient treatment file, which includes discharge abstracts of all VHA inpatient treatment. Data on service in Iraq or Afghanistan were obtained from files provided to the VA by the Department of Defense. The records of these patients were then merged to create the database examined for this study. Veterans were classified into six mutually exclusive service era categories: Korean, Vietnam, post-Vietnam, Persian Gulf exclusive of service in Iraq or Afghanistan (OIF or OEF), and OIF-OEF. A waiver of informed consent was obtained from the VA Connecticut and Yale institutional review boards.
Measures
Measures reflected patient characteristics, including age, gender, race-ethnicity, receipt of VA disability compensation, annual income, comorbid psychiatric diagnoses, and outpatient and inpatient mental health service utilization. ICD-9 codes were used to identify the following nonmutually exclusive comorbid diagnoses during the year after the first PTSD visit: schizophrenia, alcohol use disorder, drug use disorder, bipolar disorder, major depressive disorder, and dysthymia. In addition, we identified the number of outpatient mental health visits each patient had during the year after the first diagnosis of PTSD and determined whether the patient was hospitalized on an inpatient psychiatric unit that year. Veterans' residence in urban or rural areas was also included because it may also have affected access to outpatient health services. Rural-Urban Commuting Area (RUCA) classification codes developed in 1998 at the University of Washington (http://depts.washington.edu/uwruca/ruca-about.php) and national zip code data from the VA encounter files were used to identify veterans living in settings ranging from large urban locations to isolated rural ones. The zip code of residence on the first encounter record of the FY was matched with zip codes from the RUCA categories, which classified each veteran's residence as urban, large rural city, small rural community, or isolated rural setting.
In addition to the first date of a diagnosis of PTSD, we also identified the last visit that included a diagnosis of PTSD through December 2007 and subtracted that date from the date of the first PTSD visit. Retention in treatment was thus measured by the number of days from the initial PTSD diagnosis through December 2007. We also examined the number of visits specifically for the diagnosis of PTSD and the total number of specialty mental health visits regardless of diagnosis.
Statistical analysis
Descriptive statistics were used to evaluatebivariate associations betweenservice era and retention in mental health treatment, and generalized linear models (GLMs) were used to assess treatment intensity (as measured by number of visits). Survival analysis (proportional hazards regression) including all covariates was used to estimate the likelihood of dropping out of treatment during the first year after receiving a diagnosis of PTSD among OIF-OEF veterans and veterans of other war eras (Vietnam-era veterans were the reference group). SAS, version 9.1, PROC PHREG was used to perform the survival analysis.
Next, because we observed events within a defined unit of time, Poisson regressionwas used to assess the association betweenwar era and the number of visits during the first year of treatment. The analyses used PROC GENMOD of SAS and adjusted for all other covariates and duration of participation. Because of the large number of participants in the study, we set the alpha significance level to .001.
Results
The sample included 204,184 veterans; 92.8% were males. The mean age was 50.62 years, 6.8% were African American, and 1.9% were Hispanic (Table 1). Altogether 42.1% received service-connected disability benefits from the VA, and the sample had an average annual income of $25,390. About 6% had an inpatient psychiatric hospitalization during the year that they originally received a PTSD diagnosis, and 88.0% received specialty mental health services. The most frequent comorbid diagnoses among veterans diagnosed as having PTSD were dysthymia (44.5%), major depressive disorder (21.4%), and alcohol use disorder (18.6%). The majority of veterans treated for PTSD during the observed period served during the Vietnam era (59.6%), followed by those who served in OIF-OEF (14.4%).
GLMs compared the number of days veterans were retained in treatment during the first year after treatment entry, the number of mental health treatment visits attended, and the average number of visits per month. Table 2 provides details on the adjusted means and standard deviations of visit counts for veterans of each service era. Veterans of the Vietnam War were retained in PTSD treatment for an average of 247.56 days, whereas OIF-OEF veterans who were treated for PTSD were retained for 221.20 days. The adjusted mean number of outpatient visits for the treatment of PTSD among Vietnam-era veterans was 8.14, and the average number of visits for any specialty mental health services for this group was 13.37±30.38. These figures were somewhat lower for OIF-OEF veterans (6.94±13.07 and 8.15±16.90, respectively). Overall, veterans from all eras attended an average of one PTSD specialty mental health visit per month during the first year of treatment.
Bivariate data suggested that OIF-OEF veterans drop out of treatment at a moderately greater rate than their Vietnam-era counterparts. Altogether 37.6% (N=11,081) of the OIF-OEF veterans and 46.0% (N=55,896) of Vietnam-era veterans remained in treatment for more than one year. However, proportional hazards models adjusting for demographic and comorbid diagnoses showed that compared with the Vietnam-era veterans, OIF-OEF veterans were 7% less likely (hazard ratio=.93) to discontinue their psychiatric treatment for PTSD within the first year after the initial diagnosis (Table 3). Overall, veterans were less likely to drop out of treatment within the first year if they had higher income, were older, received specialty mental health services (compared with primary care medical services), had an inpatient psychiatric hospitalization, received service-connected disability benefits from the VA, or were diagnosed as having mood-related disorders (either major depressive disorder or dysthymia) (Table 3). Veterans residing in nonurban communities were less likely than those residing in urban areas to discontinue their PTSD treatment within the first year after their initial diagnosis.
Increased risk of discontinuing treatment within the first year was significantly associated with being male, being African American, and having a comorbid diagnosis of an alcohol or drug use disorder, schizophrenia, or bipolar disorder. Compared with Vietnam-era veterans, veterans who served during the Korean era, the post-Vietnam era, and the Persian Gulf era (excluding OIF-OEF veterans) were all more likely to drop out of treatment during the first year after their initial PTSD diagnosis (Table 3).
Poisson multivariate analysis indicated that compared with Vietnam-era veterans, OIF-OEF veterans had significantly more PTSD treatment visits (Table 4). Also, veterans had significantly more visits if they were older, had higher incomes, were African American, received inpatient mental health services, or had a comorbid diagnosis of alcohol or drug use disorder or a mood-related disorder. Lower numbers of PTSD-related visits were associated with being male, being Hispanic, receiving service-connected disability benefits, serving during the era of the Korean War, or living in rural areas.
Finally, we examined correlates of the number of all specialty VA mental health visits. Poisson regression suggested that veterans received more services if they were African American, received inpatient services, or had a comorbid diagnosis of an alcohol or drug use disorder, schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, or major depressive disorder (Table 4). Compared with Vietnam veterans, post-Vietnam veterans received a significantly larger number of mental health visits. Lower numbers of mental health visits were associated with receiving service-connected disability benefits from the VA and living in rural areas. Veterans who served during OIF-OEF era were not significantly different from their Vietnam-era counterparts.
Discussion
As many veterans return home from a difficult tour in a war zone, there is great concern that appropriate services be provided to facilitate their readjustment and address the physical and emotional toll of their warzone service. It has recently been documented that from 1997 to 2005 there was a steady and constant growth in the number of veterans using specialty mental health services within the VA, which was associated with an annual reduction of 37% in the number of mental health visits per veteran (20). However, there have been substantial increases in the expenditures on mental health care through FY 2008 (21) and in the average number of mental health visits per veteran with PTSD from FY 2006 to FY 2010 (unpublished data, New England Mental Illness, Research, Education, and Clinical Center, VA Connecticut Healthcare System, 2010). This study was designed in response to recent growing concerns about the retention of OIF-OEF veterans in mental health treatment.
Our data indicated that when examined independently of other factors, OIF-OEF veterans were treated for a shorter period and received fewer mental health services when compared with veterans of the Vietnam era. However, when Poisson regression was used to account for events within a defined period of time (one year after the initial diagnosis) and to adjust for potential confounds, OIF-OEF veterans were more likely than Vietnam-era veterans to be retained in treatment. Moreover, Poisson multivariate regression indicated that OIF-OEF veterans received a slightly but significantly larger dosage of specialty PTSD mental health services (number of visits adjusted for time) than their Vietnam veteran counterparts. Furthermore, no significant difference was found between OIF-OEF and Vietnam veterans in the total number of mental health specialty visits. The intensity of mental health visits were primarily associated with illness severity measured by comorbid diagnosis. It is possible that providers may have given PTSD diagnoses more readily to newly returning veterans than to older veterans, resulting in a significantly greater number of mental health visits associated with PTSD diagnosis among OIF-OEF veterans than among veterans of other eras.
Moreover, although one part of the sample (OIF-OEF veterans) is at the beginning of the course of the disorder, a new PTSD diagnosis among Vietnam-era veterans would have occurred after a considerable passage of time since the their return from overseas. In this respect, these veterans may have either suffered from this disorder for a long period and not sought any mental health services or experienced a late onset or reemergence of stress-related symptomatology (22).
Our study suggests that, on average, OIF and OEF veterans attended only eight mental health visits during the year after their initial PTSD diagnosis, and thus they were not likely to have received sufficient sessions of short-term evidence-based psychotherapy to obtain a significant reduction in symptoms in that year. Data on how many received such treatment over longer periods or on the reasons why only eight visits were received, on average, during the first year of treatment are not available.
This study also provided an opportunity to examine the patterns of mental health service use in terms of both continuity (time) and dosage (number of mental health visits) during the first year after the beginning of a new episode of treatment. This can be viewed in the perspective offered by Andersen's model (23,24) of service utilization, which suggests that service utilization is influenced by characteristics of both individuals and health care systems. Although there is a concern that OIF-OEF veterans drop out earlier and receive fewer visits, this appears to be a function of age and comorbid conditions and not the particular era in which they served. As a system, the VA offers relatively similar services to veterans of all conflict eras. However, although veterans who received service-connected disability benefits from the VA (which provide free access to services along with the monthly disability payment) had a lower risk of discontinuing mental health services within the first year after the initial PTSD diagnosis (Table 2), they also had a significantly lower number of both specialty PTSD mental health service visits or of any mental health specialty visits compared with veterans who did not receive any service-connected disability payments. These findings suggest that veterans who have no financial assistance from the VA and seek medical care within the VA health care system tend to receive more mental health services within a shorter period of time, which suggests that needs and not financial incentives drive service utilization.
Similarly, living in a rural area was associated with a significantly lower risk of terminating mental health treatment within the first year after the initial PTSD diagnosis but also with a significantly lower dosage of both PTSD mental health service and any mental health services. These findings suggest that geographical barriers may restrict the intensity of services but do not interfere with treatment retention.
This study has several limitations that restrict our ability to draw definitive conclusions about the nature of service use among VA patients with PTSD, especially among those who served in Iraq or Afghanistan. First, the study used administrative data on diagnosis, the validity of which has not been determined, and further data on severity of illness were not available. Second, we have no information on non-VA mental health service use by these veterans, which may have resulted in an underestimation of service utilization, especially among veterans who did not receive service-connected disability benefits. However, there is evidence from the Vietnam generation that veterans with PTSD are far more likely to use VA services than non-VA services and that the delivery of services for PTSD in populations supported by private insurance is far more uncommon than is the delivery of such services in the VA (25).
Conclusions
Although there are growing concerns that OIF-OEF veterans are dropping out of PTSD treatment prematurely and receiving fewer mental health visits than veterans of other eras, this observation appears to be primarily a function of age and comorbid conditions and not the particular era in which they served. Our data highlight the need for additional efforts to ensure that these veterans receive the services they need and that the services are readily available from the VA health care system. VA expenditures on mental health care have increased by hundreds of millions of dollars in recent years, in part, to increase the availability of services for these veterans (21). Policy makers and clinicians should be aware of the higher risk of treatment dropout associated with younger age. Interventions should be developed to target specific barriers to care that interfere with veterans' willingness to attend specialized mental health services.
Acknowledgments and disclosures
The authors report no competing interests.
References
1.
Hoge CW, Castro CA, Messer SC, et al.: Combat duty in Iraq and Afghanistan, mental health problems, and barriers to care. New England Journal of Medicine 351:13–22, 2004
2.
Hoge CW, Auchterlonie JL, Milliken CS: Mental health problems, use of mental health services, and attrition from military service after returning from deployment to Iraq or Afghanistan. JAMA 295:1023–1032, 2006
3.
Jordan BK, Schlenger WE, Hough R, et al.: Lifetime and current prevalence of specific psychiatric disorders among Vietnam veterans and controls. Archives of General Psychiatry 48:207–215, 1991
4.
Hoge CW, Lesikar SE, Guevara R, et al.: Mental disorders among US military personnel in the 1990s: association with high levels of health care utilization and early military attrition. American Journal of Psychiatry 159:1576–1583, 2002
5.
Hoge CW, Toboni HE, Messer SC, et al.: The occupational burden of mental disorders in the US military: psychiatric hospitalizations, involuntary separations, and disability. American Journal of Psychiatry 162:585–591, 2005
6.
Kessler RC, Berglund PA, Bruce ML, et al.: The prevalence and correlates of untreated serious mental illness. Health Services Research 36:987–1007, 2001
7.
Kessler RC, Sonnega A, Bromet E, et al.: Posttraumatic stress disorder in the National Comorbidity Survey. Archives of General Psychiatry 52:1048–1060, 1995
8.
Hourani LL, Yuan H: The mental health status of women in the Navy and Marine Corps: preliminary findings from the Perceptions of Wellness and Readiness Assessment. Military Medicine 164:174–181, 1999
9.
Brandt LW: Studies of “dropout” patients in psychotherapy: a review of findings. Psychotherapy: Theory, Research and Practice 2:6–12, 1965
10.
Hiler EW: An analysis of patient-therapist compatibility. Journal of Consulting Psychology 22:341–347, 1958
11.
Rogers C: Client-Centered Therapy: Its Current Practice, Implications and Theory. Boston, Houghton Mifflin, 1951
12.
Garfield S, Affleck D, Muffly R: A study of psychotherapy interaction and continuation in psychotherapy. Journal of Clinical Psychology 19:473–478, 1963
13.
Garfield SL: Research on client variables in psychotherapy; in Handbook of Psychotherapy and Behavior Change, 4th ed. Edited by, Bergin AEG, Sol L. New York, Wiley, 1994
14.
Harpaz-Rotem I, Leslie D, Rosenheck RA: Treatment retention among children entering a new episode of mental health care. Psychiatric Services 55:1022–1028, 2004
15.
Sparks WA, Daniels JA, Johnson E: Relationship of referral source, race, and wait time on preintake attrition. Professional Psychology: Research and Practice 34:514–518, 2003
16.
Wierzbicki M, Pekarik G: A meta-analysis of psychotherapy dropout. Professional Psychology: Research and Practice 24:190–195, 1993
17.
Phillips EL: Psychotherapy Revised: New Frontiers in Research and Practice. Hillsdale, NJ, Erlbaum, 1985
18.
Foa EB, Keane TM, Friedman M: Effective Treatments for PTSD: Practice Guideline From the International Society of Traumatic Stress Studies. New York, Guilford, 2000
19.
Beck AT: The current state of cognitive therapy: a 40-year retrospective. Archives of General Psychiatry 62:953–959, 2005
20.
Rosenheck RA, Fontana AF: Recent trends in VA treatment of post-traumatic stress disorder and other mental disorders. Health Affairs 26:1720–1727, 2007
21.
Greenberg G, Rosenheck R: National Mental Health Program Performance Monitoring System: Fiscal Year 2008 Report. West Haven, Conn, Northeast Program Evaluation Center, 2009
22.
Port CL, Engdahl B, Frazier P: A longitudinal and retrospective study of PTSD among older prisoners of war. American Journal of Psychiatry 158:1474–1479, 2001
23.
Andersen R: A Behavioral Model of Families' Use of Health Services. Chicago, University of Chicago Press, 1968
24.
Andersen RM: Revisiting the behavioral model and access to medical care: does it matter? Journal of Health and Social Behavior 36:1–10, 1995
25.
Rosenheck R, Fontana A: Do Vietnam-era veterans who suffer from posttraumatic stress disorder avoid VA mental health services? Military Medicine 160:136–142, 1995
Figures and Tables
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Cover: View Across Frenchman's Bay From Mt. Desert Island, After a Squall, by Thomas Cole, 1845. Oil on canvas, 38 × 62 inches. Cincinnati Art Museum, gift of Alice Scarborough.
History
Published online: 1 January 2011
Published in print: January 2011
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Export Citations
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.
For more information or tips please see 'Downloading to a citation manager' in the Help menu.
View Options
View options
PDF/EPUB
View PDF/EPUBGet Access
Login options
Already a subscriber? Access your subscription through your login credentials or your institution for full access to this article.
Personal login Institutional Login Open Athens loginNot a subscriber?
PsychiatryOnline subscription options offer access to the DSM-5-TR® library, books, journals, CME, and patient resources. This all-in-one virtual library provides psychiatrists and mental health professionals with key resources for diagnosis, treatment, research, and professional development.
Need more help? PsychiatryOnline Customer Service may be reached by emailing [email protected] or by calling 800-368-5777 (in the U.S.) or 703-907-7322 (outside the U.S.).